Horton Grand Hotel San Diego

The Horton Grand Hotel and Suites

Hotel Class: 3 out of 5 stars3 Stars - 2 Reviews and 180 Opinions

311 Island Ave., San Diego, California, 92101, United States

  • Map
    This Hotel
  • Hotel
    Photos
  • Hotel
    Amenities

Check Rates and Availability


View deals from our list of partners

Opens one window for each offer. Please disable pop-up blockers.

 

71%

of people enjoy staying here

3.5 our of 5 stars 182 Opinions

Excellent
 
47
Very Good
 
53
Average
 
31
Poor
 
24
Terrible
 
27

Our Members Say

  • TravellerMel profile photo
  • Reviews: 548

5 out of 5 starsUser Rating

Romantic Rendezvous

My favorite hotel ever - I've spent some of my most romantic days (and nights) here. The rooms are decorated beautifully, and my favorite memory is retrieving the notebook left on the fireplace, reading notes from the rooms previous tenants, and adding our own. I would absolutely recommend this hotel!

Unique Quality: Formerly a high-class brothel in the1800s, this is now a charming and elegant boutique hotel. Each room is unique and decorated with Victorian era antiques. Perfect for a romantic rendezvous as the hotel is lovely and very close to the downtown activities, restaurants and entertainment.

  • Opinion of Price: more expensive than average
  • Related to: Romantic Travel and Honeymoons

Was this Horton Grand Hotel San Diego review helpful?

  • lmkluque profile photo
  • Reviews: 1482

5 out of 5 starsUser Rating

1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

History of The Gaslamp Quarter?

Each room is unique in style and focus, and though all the amenities are present, they are discretely hidden from view to retain the charm of the room. (For example, a TV may be found behind the doors of an armoire.) I haven't stayed at this hotel but took a tour soon after completion. One thing I found most interesting was a small book on the mantle piece provided for the guest's comments during their stay. Imagine reading little stories left behind sharing the history of that room.

Luxury: The Grand Horton was originally built in 1887 as a replica of the Innsbruck Inn in Vienna, Austria, in what is called, Italianate Victorian architecture style. The beautiful oak staircase that can be seen in the Palace Bar was sent to Austria to be restored to it's youthful condition.

Blue Collar: Originally called the Brooklyn Hotel, this Cowboy/Victorian hotel built in the late 1880's also, later became known as the Kahle Saddlery Hotel, after the prominent saddle and harness shop that occupied the ground floor in 1912.

Wyatt Earp lived in this hotel most of the seven years he resided in San Diego.

Plans for the demolition of both hotels were halted in 1979 when the City of San Diego bought them.

Unique Quality: The City dismantled the two historical San Diego hotels were and reconstructed them, brick by brick. A glass atrim was built between the two which turned out to be a pretty nice addition. They were place at Fourth and Island Avenue, a quiet side street, in the early days of the Gaslamp Quarter.

One hotel was a 'working man's' hotel and the facade has simple, plain lines. The other hotel, (Pictured here,) attracted the wealthier client and the facade is more ornate.

The second photo shows the "Working Man's Side" of the two hotels used. (4th & Island)

The original names of the two hotels are, The Grand Horton Hotel which opened in 1886 and the Brooklyn Kahle Saddlery Hotel which opened during the same time period to accommodate the great surge of people moving into the area.


The restaurant in the hotel is 'Ida Bailey's' named for the Infamous Madame of The Yellow House, one of the classiest brothels in San Diego, popular during the time Wyatt Erap lived here.

The Palace Bar, once a favorite 'watering hole' for the locals, and a beautiful oak staircase are situated in the hotel as well. In the bar area, on some afternoons, High Tea is served.

FYI:
There was a small sample of the San Diego Chinese Historical Museum dedicated to the Chinese laborers, who helped build San Diego in the early days, located in the atrim. I don't know if it is still at the Hotel Grand but it does have it's own building at 404 Third Avenue, San Diego, CA 9210, which is about a block away. So, worth a stop while staying at the Horton Grand. The admission is about two dollars.

  • Opinion of Price: about average
  • Related to: Romantic Travel and Honeymoons, Historical Travel, Business Travel
Horton Grand Hotel San Diego Photo: The Luxury Side

Horton Grand Hotel San Diego Photo: The Luxury Side

1 more images

Was this Horton Grand Hotel San Diego review helpful?

Write a Review

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

More about Horton Grand Hotel San Diego

A Long Running Comedy

by lmkluque about Horton Grand Theatre

Now playing, "ESPRESSO!"

Well, Espresso has been playing here for many years and doesn't look as if it will be leaving soon.

Horton Grand Theatre, once known as the Hahn Cosmopolitan Theatre, is located on the Fourth Avenue side of The Horton Grand Hotel and near plenty of restaurants to stop in for dinner or a drink, before and after the play.

This is not a flashy place, a flat brick building with only an awning and big sign painted in the window to let you know what it is, but the comedy, "Triple Espresso," is pretty funny and continues to bring in the crowds.

Wednesday through Sunday, with early showings on Saturday and Sunday, the play can be seen and tickets run about $35.00. Children under five years will not be permitted in the theater. Dress your best. Even though this is not "Broadway," it still feels good to walk into the theater in style.

Gaslamp Quarter-Horton Grand Hotel

by Dabs

The Horton Grand Hotel is actually two 1886 hotels that were slated for demolition but fortunately saved, moved here from other sites, renovated and connected by an atrium; the original Grand Horton on the left, the Brooklyn Hotel (aka Kahle Saddlery Hotel) on the right. The Grand Horton building was built by a German immigrant to look like the Innsbruck Inn in Vienna, the Brooklyn Hotel had more of a cowboy flavor, indeed Wyatt Earp resided here for 7 years. This was the only building I went inside while touring the Gaslamp Quarter and it's worth a stop even if you aren't staying here.

In the lobby you'll find a life size papier mache horse named Sunshine which originally stood in front of the Brooklyn Hotel when the ground floor was a saddle shop. The reception desk is a recycled pew from a choir loft, old post-office boxes now hold guests' keys. In the hotel's Palace Bar, there is a portrait of local madam Ida Bailey, her brothel, the Canary Cottage, once stood a couple of blocks away.

And what historic hotel would be complete without their own resident ghost, if you stay here in room 309 you may be visited by Roger Whitaker who seems to be a friendly ghost, the theories are that he was either shot by his future father in law and dumped near where the hotels were relocated or that he was a gambler caught cheating at cards at the hotel, ran back to room 309 and was shot through the door.

There was a sign in the lobby stating that there was a historical tour on Wednesdays at 3:00pm, it didn't specify if you had to be staying there or if there was a charge.

Disappointed

by A TripAdvisor Member

The room itself was nice, not anything special, just nice. It had the basic ammenities and nothing more. What was horrible was the noise!! I don't know what was going on but there was raucous music being played very loudly from 9pm until midnight. There was a guest above us who made so much noise walking around that I thought he was going to fall through the ceiling. The street noise never stops all night and the trash trucks come by at 5 am and create such a racket that going back to sleep is near impossible. When I asked the girl at the desk the next morning what all the music was about the night before she just shrugged and said "I think there was a sorority party going on." She wasn't even sure about what was going on in the very place she works at! Definitely spend your well earned money somewhere else where it is quiet!

Worst Hotel experience in my life

by TripAdvisor Member AP_Phoenix

Reserved a room for the weekend- Friday March 4 2005- March 6. The hotel room was so loud that I was woken up repeateadly throughout the night. Finally, around 2 am my boyfriend and I packed up and changed rooms. The hotel staff was indifferent, as if these types of complaints happened regularly. Not to mention, that our balcony door room was broken so a cold draft blew directly onto the bed where I was trying to sleep. When I complained about the draft, the desk clerk said- Oh yeah, the heat's broken in that room... Why in the world would they have put us there then?? We checked out the next morning.

If you want the world's most horrible night's sleep, book the Horton Grand.

Continued Parking Problems

by TripAdvisor Member taschenck

It turns from reading the reviews on this site that I'm not the only one who encountered parking problems at this hotel (see reviews on 8/11/03, 9/13/03 and 9/9/04). I attended a seminar at this hotel and will seek to avoid attending future seminars if they are held at this location. I am typically not one to criticize because I like to give others the benefit of the doubt that an unfortunate event which resulted in a poor experience is just that, an unfortunate event. I am compelled to speak up in this situation because I see my experience as just one of many similar experiences faced by other guests with service at this hotel, not just parking, and I do not see the situation getting better.

The Horton Grand does not offer self-parking but in its place does offer, what I consider, inexpensive valet parking. The problem is the valet parking lot seems to be frequently full and thus you are left on your own to find parking. The redevelopment boom in San Diego has eliminated many of the parking lots that used to be close to this hotel's location. Thus, if you are disabled or if you have luggage to carry, plan on walking 3 - 4 city blocks to reach the hotel. (The nearest lot is 1 1/2 blocks away but is often full or has no one available to pay.)

I would follow the recommendation made by a reviewer on 9/19/03 to offer the bellman (assuming you can get his attention) $40 to park your car for you. I spoke to the bellman seeking a closer parking spot because of my walking disability and was told there was nothing he could do. I spoke to the front desk who told me to call the General Manager. I sent a letter to the General Manager and never heard back. I used to work in hotel management and would be embarrassed by this level of service. In my experience, we promptly responded to every known complaint.

The Horton Grand is in a nice location and has a lot of potential considering its history. I just hope they finally take the consistently poor reviews they are receiving at this site seriously. I also want to offer my thanks to TripAdvisor for providing this venue to either praise or criticize hotels and other establishments.

Never go here ever! Looks are deceiving

by TripAdvisor Member jamesandcarys

You might be wanting to be optimistic as we were but the same problems will probably happen to you as with all the other bad reviews.

Ok here they are:

Totally rude service and at times a distinct contempt from the staff at the desk.

Weekend noise is very loud and penetrates the room easily.

The walls are paper thin and you can quite easily listen to conversations televisions or other things from next door.

With the problems the price becomes far too high with everything an optional extra.

One good thing is the decor of the rooms including ye olde toilet, but thats about it.

Plenty of other better places to stay in lovely san diego.

GREAT, FUN, CLOSE TO PETCO

by TripAdvisor Member Christypix

I am always kinda scared of getting a hotel online when I have never seen the hotel in person, or received any recommendations from a friend. BUT I was very pleased with this hotel. I took a quick, last minute trip to san diego to watch a padre game and have some drinks at the gaslamp district. I thought the hotel was perfect for the price i paid ($130.00). We had a corner view of the gas lamp district. THe room was comfortable and clean, they had a victorian decor (cute). You walk out the door and there the fun begins. Petco was about four blocks away! I think the only thing that some maybe concerned about was the noise... yes it's noisey but what do you expect when you are in the middle of gaslamp... i was there to have a good time and be part of the noise!

No bang for your buck

by A TripAdvisor Member

For the price, this place was very disappointing. First of all, there was no parking available. The valet's indicated that they can only accommodate 80 cars although there are 138+ rooms. The closest parking parking was about (3) blocks away and $28 per night. Next the rooms were very small and the carpet was flithy. The walls and ceilings were paper thin. We could hear the street noise but it calmed down when the bars closed. For the price, I would not recommend this hotel. I have stayed in midtown NYC for the same price with clean rooms, heavenly beds, etc. The hotel staff gave me the impression that they didn't care if you return or not.

Photos

Horton Grand HotelHorton Grand Hotel

Horton Grand HotelHorton Grand Hotel

Forum Posts

Gaslamp District-Old Victorian Hotel

by azsk8fan

I'm trying to find the name of an old Victorian style hotel located in gaslamp district in San Diego. I walked through the lobby and it is so pretty I'd like to stay there on my next trip but I can't remember the name and whenever I look up hotels in San Diego I don't seem to find anything that could be it.

RE: Gaslamp District-Old Victorian Hotel

by lmkluque

Was it the Horton Grand Hotel? That is the closest to Victorian that I can think of in the Gaslamp Quarter. There str a couple of photos of it on my SD page.

Hope this helps,
Linda

Travelers also viewed

The Place

 

The People

 
Our Members Say
lmkluque profile photo

 The City dismantled the two historical San Diego hotels were and reconstructed them, brick by brick. A glass atrim was built between the two which turned out to be a pretty nice addition. They were place at Fourth and Island Avenue, a quiet side street, in the early days of the Gaslamp Quarter.

One hotel was a 'working man's' hotel and the facade has simple, plain lines. The other hotel, (Pictured here,) attracted the wealthier client and the facade is more ornate.

The second photo shows the "Working Man's Side" of the two hotels used. (4th & Island)

The original names of the two hotels are, The Grand Horton Hotel which opened in 1886 and the Brooklyn Kahle Saddlery Hotel which opened during the same time period to accommodate the great surge of people moving into the area.


The restaurant in the hotel is 'Ida Bailey's' named for the Infamous Madame of The Yellow House, one of the classiest brothels in San Diego, popular during the time Wyatt Erap lived here.

The Palace Bar, once a favorite 'watering hole' for the locals, and a beautiful oak staircase are situated in the hotel as well. In the bar area, on some afternoons, High Tea is served.

FYI:
There was a small sample of the San Diego Chinese Historical Museum dedicated to the Chinese laborers, who helped build San Diego in the early days, located in the atrim. I don't know if it is still at the Hotel Grand but it does have it's own building at 404 Third Avenue, San Diego, CA 9210, which is about a block away. So, worth a stop while staying at the Horton Grand. The admission is about two dollars. 

2822 members live in San Diego

 

Questions and Answers

estellechou profile photo

Q: A cheap Hotel in a good Neighborhood in San Diego "Hi guys, We are two french students and we will do a road trip on the west coast, we will stay from the 14th of july until the..."

bocmaxima profile photo

A: "You should look at a youth hostel. Either the Banana Bungalow or the HI San Diego Downtown, both of which are in the Downtown area. Failing that, the Dolphin Motel is..."

Read 4 Replies ยป
postQuestion_button

Latest San Diego hotel reviews

Kona Kai Resort
273 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 29, 2012
Crowne Plaza Hotel San Diego - Mission Valley
284 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Rancho Bernardo Inn
430 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Ramada Mission Valley / SDSU
55 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 25, 2012
Courtyard By Marriott San Diego Rancho Bernardo
63 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 26, 2012
Mission Bay Inn San Diego
32 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 23, 2012
Lafayette Hotel San Diego
178 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 26, 2012
Days Inn San Diego Downtown/Convention Center
42 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 8, 2012
Pacific Shores Inn Pacific Beach
190 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 2, 2012
Hard Rock Hotel San Diego
914 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Motel 6 San Diego - Hotel Circle
44 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Mar 10, 2012
Super 8 Motel - San Diego Zoo
14 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 24, 2012
Holiday Inn Express Hotel And Suites Sorrento Valley
50 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 21, 2012
Town and Country Resort Hotel
869 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Comfort Inn Mission Bay SeaWorld Area
6 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 27, 2012

 Horton Grand Hotel San Diego

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

The Horton Grand Hotel

Address: 311 Island Ave., San Diego, California, 92101, United States

[Hide]

Check Rates and Availability (from our partners)