Renoir Hotel

Renoir Hotel

Hotel Class: 2.5 out of 5 stars2.5 Stars - 3 Reviews and 321 Opinions

45 Mcallister Street, San Francisco, California, 94102, United States

  • Map
    This Hotel
  • Hotel
    Photos
  • Hotel
    Amenities

Check Rates and Availability


View deals from our list of partners

Opens one window for each offer. Please disable pop-up blockers.

 

41%

of people enjoy staying here

2.5 our of 5 stars 324 Opinions

Excellent
 
13
Very Good
 
50
Average
 
54
Poor
 
64
Terrible
 
96

Our Members Say

  • amberll profile photo
  • Reviews: 5
Avoid this hotel

I almost stayed here but canceled my trip (and did not receive the $800 refund). After reading about this place on tripadvisor.com, I could not do it. Please go to this website if you are even thinking of staying here. We booked a different hotel and when our airport shuttle driver drove us past the Renoir he said we would have been crazy to stay there.

Here are some of best (and most entertaining) reviews I could find of the hotel from tripadvisor. I don't even mind that I lost $800 to avoid this place:

If you are into urine, vomit, homeless, porn establishments, contact with local law enforcement and the such, this will be your Disneyland. And this is all before you get to the front door! I am a former military police officer and am currently a lineman for a public utilites company and am use to working in the more difficult and dangerous areas of San Diego. I have spent my career going into homes and businesses and dealing with difficult people in dangerous areas but this was a total cartoon!!

The hotel itself is as it is billed. Bulit in 1909, but hasn't changed much since. We had a "heater" in our room which looked alot like the radiator out of a '70s Ford pick up truck. I think the beds and bathroom were there more for decor as they weren't functional at all unless you just begged enough money or sold enough crack cocaine on the street out front to secure a room for the night. The paint and carpeting are obvious originals which adds to a very faint and definate odour to compliment the fact that you are in fact in the 5th ring of hell (refere to Dante's 'Inferno') However this is the only mentionable quality of the "hotel" as this actually masks the unique aroma of fresh puke and ---- arising from the bowels of the streets of San Franpuko. If the owners of The Renior are looking for a marketing ploy and need a catch phrase, might I suggest the following........"The Renior Hotel.....only a gallon of gas and a matchstick away from perfection!!"

Here is another great review:

My boyfriend and I spent a night in this hotel about 2 years ago and we are still laughing about it. We made our reservation through Orbitz, who rated the hotel a 3 star I think. Paul and I live in NYC, so when we saw homeless people in front of our hotel, we thought little of it.
As we were checking in, a homeless women entered the hotel lobby. She hid behind a poll, expecting not to be seen. When the worker at the desk asked her if she needed help she tried to sneak on the elevator. She was escorted from the hotel. Shortly thereafter, a homeless man entered the lobby. He too, tried to sneak on the elevator. When confronted, he insisted on using the lobby bathroom. The worker behind the desk gave in, and allowed the man to use the bathroom. While this was happening, I heard yelling coming from the street. I walked to the door to see what was going on. To this day, I'm still not sure what was happening that night, but for those of you who have seen the Thriller video or the Pat Benetar's "love is a battlefield" video, it was very similar. Homeless people were marching down the street in what almost seemed to be a choreographed routine.
At this point we had seen enough. Weary from travel, and clearly too fatigued to make a clear decision, Paul and I headed away from the homeless people, who were then congregating in the lobby, and into the elevator.
There was a strange man in the elevator who repeatedly asked us to which floor we were headed. When we got out on the same floor, I was nervous. When I saw that the strange man was staying in the room next to me, I was more nervous. When I saw that we had an adjoining room with a broken lock, I panicked. We called downstairs. There was nothing they could do. I noticed blood on our curtains. A homeless man from the street below started yelling something at me. I tried to close the window, but there was no screen. That wouldn't have been a problem is we had AC in the room, but we didn't and it was very hot.
At that point, we had had enough. We got on the phone with Orbitz, they coached us through the night, and by dawn, we were on our way to find a new hotel.

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.

  • Opinion of Price: less expensive than average
  • Related to: Singles, Family Travel, Business Travel

Was this Renoir Hotel review helpful?

  • LoriPori profile photo
  • Reviews: 2773

5 out of 5 starsUser Rating

4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

SAN FRANCISCO GEM

The RENOIR HOTEL is located right in the heart of downtown San Francisco. It is close to major stores, like Macy's, close to restaurants and take-out food, and a short walking distance to the start of the Cable Cars on Powell Street.
Hans and I stayed here for two nights, Thursday August 5 and Friday August 6.

Unique Quality: Although our room was small as we reserved an economy room, it was sufficient for us. The hotel lobby had a lounge area where you can read or just watch the hustle bustle of a busy hotel. The front desk was friendly and always helpful. A busboy is available if you need your suitcases brought up to your room.

  • Opinion of Price: about average
Renoir Hotel Photo: Lori & the Renoir

Renoir Hotel Photo: Lori & the Renoir


Was this Renoir Hotel review helpful?

  • Waalewiener profile photo
  • Reviews: 1129

4 out of 5 starsUser Rating

4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

An old but beautiful restored Hotel with class.

This Hotel was very nice , great location ,and the Lobby was refurbished and it was done very very nice ,with high ceilings moldings and a lot of brass on the elevator doors.
The rooms were ok pretty standard not to big ,our window looked out at Market street
This Hotel is very reasonable priced if you find it through an internet site it was $68 + Tax came to about $77 dollar U S .
The room was clean and the Staff was very nice and very good
I recommend this Hotel ,it was very good

Unique Quality: We did not eat in the Hotel so I can't speak on the food .
Well we were warned that this Hotel was located in a very '' seedy '' area of San Francisco .
Well through our travels we seen all type of places fancy and not so fancy .
If they mean by '' seedy '' the many men and homeless people that hang around all day ,well there were many homeless people in this area .
At no time did we feel threatened or uncomftable by these people ,They did not bother us ,just the odd person would ask for something but no worse then anywhere else in a big City
We had a great 3 nights and 4 days here in this downtown San Francisco area ,Lots of hussle and bussle .

  • Opinion of Price: less expensive than average
Renoir Hotel Photo: Renoir  Hotel

Renoir Hotel Photo: Renoir Hotel


Was this Renoir Hotel review helpful?

Write a Review

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

More about Renoir Hotel

SAN FRANCISCO GEM

by LoriPori about RENOIR HOTEL

The RENOIR HOTEL is located right in the heart of downtown San Francisco. It is close to major stores, like Macy's, close to restaurants and take-out food, and a short walking distance to the start of the Cable Cars on Powell Street.
Hans and I stayed here for two nights, Thursday August 5 and Friday August 6. Although our room was small as we reserved an economy room, it was sufficient for us. The hotel lobby had a lounge area where you can read or just watch the hustle bustle of a busy hotel. The front desk was friendly and always helpful. A busboy is available if you need your suitcases brought up to your room.

Are you nuts?

by TripAdvisor Member NancyG13

Oh my God! This is the worst hotel I have ever seen in my life. Escaping the 20-30 smelliest homeless people I have ever experienced I stepped into a run down dingy lobby. From there, the rude Manager checked us in. When we arrived in our room it too was dingy and seemed unclean. It was so small you could swing a sock around and hit all four walls. The sounds of sirens all night and screaming people in the streets didn't seem so bad after we found a cockroach on the wall. We checked out 3 days early, and would not recommend this experience to anyone at all. Do not stay here!! I would suggest sleeping in your car if you can't find any other place to stay.

Not as Bad as Some Reviewers Suggest

by TripAdvisor Member nwalesguy

I have stayed at this Hotel on two different occassions the most recent being March, 2003. Yes the Hotel is located in an undesireable area. However, within 5 mins walk you are in the very attractive area around Union Square. I opted for an economy room last time I visited - this being an internal room meant that there was no street noise. The room was very clean and for the price was very good value indeed. Yes there are a lot of homeless people all around - however, in my experience they do not beg and did not hassle me at all. Just don't look like a tourist and you will be fine. This is an OK hotel for couples and single men - single women may feel a little more uncomfortable due to the location.

Pay more money and stay somewhere else

by A TripAdvisor Member

We were there in June 2004. Once you get past the lobby, the hotel is dingy at best. The hotel has no AC, which means that you need to keep the window open so that you can hear the trolley and the all night noise from the large population of street people very well. The huge neon sign on the porn theater across the street adds delightful ambiance to the experience, as do the inhabitants of the flop house across the street from the rear entrance of the hotel.

Pay more money and stay somewhere else.

An unexpected surprise

by A TripAdvisor Member

The hotel lobby is decent. The rest basically like a Motel 6. The staff was excellent. HOWEVER...the hotel is surrounded on all sides by vagrants, druggies, dirty movies, peep shows, etc. I was afraid to walk around...took taxi's most places. The bus was fairly close so we had no problem during the day. Next time before booking a trip, I will check the internet. Staying in the neighborhood is not for the feeble hearted.

Nice Hotel - I really liked it.

by A TripAdvisor Member

Really nice hotel. One of the cheapest we could actually find downtown....Yes, we saw somw homeless, if there are actually all around the city...It is quite sad...but we had fun!
Staff was really nice and helpfull!

Red Light district- law abiding citizens stay away

by A TripAdvisor Member

The hotel is located across from a strip club, our first day in San Fran. while we were walking back to the hotel we were offered crack (so if you are a crack head this might be the hotel to stay in, easy access to strippers, hookers and of course drugs) The hotel manager told us that homlessness is a city wide problem, while there are a lot of homeless people in San Fran. the hotel seemed to be the headquarter. Let's not make a mistake, homlessness is not THE problem it is the location of the hotel and its other "residents"... They would not refund my money (I made reservation through orbitz.com) so we had to spend our entire trip there. A single woman should NOT stay in this hotel under any circumstances.

Forum Posts

visiting san fransico

by mangowood

My wife and I will be visiting between September 22-28, where is the best place to stay, my wife booked the Renoir. We looking for a place close to night life, museums, visiting Alcatraz, shopping,etc.

Any advice would be appreciated.

Re: visiting san fransico

by Agraichen

Perhaps you should check some of the online comments about this location: http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g60713-d80799-Reviews-Renoir_Hotel-San_Francisco_California.html . I know the location only and can not actually comment on the facility other than it would not be high on my list of places to stay in SF.

Re: visiting san fransico

by rkearns

there's tons of info on the VT accommodations page.

Re: visiting san fransico

by mangowood

thank you for the link. after reviewing the past experiences of others we will be looking for other places to stay. definately not for us.

Re: visiting san fransico

by Agraichen

BTW I sent you a number of hotel links via VT email. All are on in the Wharf area but are close to tourist attractions and all have easy access to Muni and the Light Rail system for additional touring.

Re: visiting san fransico

by yvr

I would suggest you pick another hotel. This hotel is not in the best area. It is an old hotel and for the most part the reviews about it are not very nice. The area is surrounded by homeless people and pan handlers. While there have been some impovements in the area it is still not the best place to see the city in a favorable light. This part of Market Street has a long way to go before it will start to shine again.

Re: visiting san fransico

by rkearns

i don't know what your budget is, but the mariott on 4th and market is just fine. the palomar is nice, good location. i would also recommend the W.

Re: visiting san francisco

by mangowood

Thank you all for the links, e-mails, and suggestions. We settled on The Palace, rooms were scarce throughout the city on our trip due to conventions. The hotel was pretty centrally located based on all we wanted to see/tour in the city, plus the reviews were great. Again all help is very much appreciated, my wife and I are greatful and can't thank everyone enough.

Re: visiting san fransico

by yvr

The Palace was one of the Grand Hotels of an era gone by. Be sure and visit the dinning room in the hotel, if not to eat but just to look, it is beautiful.

Travelers also viewed

The Place

 

The People

 
Our Members Say
Waalewiener profile photo

 We did not eat in the Hotel so I can't speak on the food .
Well we were warned that this Hotel was located in a very '' seedy '' area of San Francisco .
Well through our travels we seen all type of places fancy and not so fancy .
If they mean by '' seedy '' the many men and homeless people that hang around all day ,well there were many homeless people in this area .
At no time did we feel threatened or uncomftable by these people ,They did not bother us ,just the odd person would ask for something but no worse then anywhere else in a big City
We had a great 3 nights and 4 days here in this downtown San Francisco area ,Lots of hussle and bussle . 

4084 members live in San Francisco

 

Questions and Answers

Lorys79 profile photo

Q: San Francisco where to have a drink? "Hi could you please suggest some nice restaurant or good place for a drink in rcastro union square? Where can we find a place for..."

TooTallFinn24 profile photo

A: "My favorite place for a drink in Union Square is the Burritt Room. The bar is located within the Crescent Hotel at 417 Stockton Street. Its a classic bar and is..."

Read 5 Replies »
postQuestion_button

Latest San Francisco hotel reviews

Hotel Triton - A Kimpton Hotel
439 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 12, 2012
Best Western Tuscan Inn At Fishermans Wharf
988 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 11, 2012
Monticello Inn - A Kimpton Hotel
453 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 12, 2012
Holiday Inn Civic Center
268 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Dec 28, 2011
Galleria Park Hotel
583 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 7, 2012
InterContinental Mark Hopkins
705 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 12, 2012
Fairmont San Francisco
932 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 13, 2012
Motel 6 San Francisco Downtown
50 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Nov 23, 2011
White Swan Inn
417 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 5, 2012
Grosvenor Suites
456 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 12, 2012
The Opal San Francisco
404 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 8, 2012
Hilton San Francisco
1854 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 12, 2012
Marina Inn San Francisco
158 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 11, 2012
Grant Plaza Hotel
306 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 2, 2012
Hotel Whitcomb San Francisco
740 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jan 11, 2012

 Renoir Hotel

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

Renoir Hotel San Francisco
Renoir San Francisco

Address: 45 Mcallister Street, San Francisco, California, 94102, United States