Hotel Carmel

2 out of 5 stars2 Stars

201 Broadway, Santa Monica, California, 90401, United States

1 Review

Hotel Carmel
Enter dates for best prices
Compare best prices from top travel partners
Hotels.com Booking.com Travelocity

58%

Satisfaction Terrible
Excellent
8%
28
Very Good
27%
93
Average
23%
78
Poor
18%
62
Terrible
21%
72

Value Score Poor Value

Costs 47% more and rated 11% lower than other 2 star hotels

Show Prices

Good For Couples
  • Families46
  • Couples46
  • Solo40
  • Business37
  • volarevolare's Profile Photo

    Hotel Carmel

    by

    You'd save a lot with the coupon from the discount book, but then again, that means no advance reservation.

    You have to walk in for the discount rate with the discount coupon.

    Unique Quality: Conveniently situated. Walking distance to major attractions like the Santa Monica Pier and 3rd Street Promenade.

More about Hotel Carmel

disappointing

by A TripAdvisor Member

I stayed in the hotel Carmel this August, I found the hotel to smell, the rooms to be cramped, the staff unprofessional and rude, my booking was lost and i was forced to accpet a diferent room, when i complained to my travel booker, the hotel reponsed saying the matter was closed without answering my question at all. I would not advise anyone to stay in this hotel ,as the staff and the condition of the hotel , will put u in a damperer on ur trip to such a wonderful place like santa monica

Elegant Hotel.

by A TripAdvisor Member

I stayed at the Hotel Carmel for 2 nights in July and was really quite dreading it after reading some of the reviews on this site. But I was very pleasantly surprised. On arrival the staff couldn't have been more helpful. We had a horrendous journey with a shuttle firm that we had booked in New Zealand and the receptionist suggested an alternative firm to travel back to the airport with who proved to much better. The staff also organised transport for us to Universal Studios advising us on the best times to go, which proved correct. The rooms are small and dark by US standards but the beautiful furniture, including big comfortable bed, and the elegant atmosphere really made up for this. The location was fantastic, a couple of minutes walk to all the shops and restaurants you could need and only a few minutes to the beach and pier. I would certainly stay there again. I wouls also recommend the hotel to friends, particularly those who appreciate old and elegant charm.

Great location, but that's about all.

by A TripAdvisor Member

The hotel looks rather grand from the outside, and even promising as you enter the lobby, however I found our room, itself, rather disappointing. It was small and cramped, and had none of the facilities offered by the other hotels I stayed at during my visit to the United States (no coffee machine or kettle, no hairdryer, no fridge). Our ground floor room looked directly into a completely enclosed courtyard housing some sort of large machinery/pipeline. Granted, as I am on a budget, I chose the simplest room on offer - yet I paid more for a room at the Carmel than I did for any other room during my stay in the USA, and I was most disappointed with it.
There is limited roadside parking in the area (as it is just one street away from the 3rd Street Promenade), thus our only option was to have our car valet-parked - not a problem when dropping the car off, but I waited up to twenty minutes to have it brought to me each time I needed it.
The Hotel Carmel does have its plus points, however. It was clean, and for the most part, the staff was friendly. What it has most in its favour is its location - it's just a block from the 3rd Street Promenade, and a couple of blocks in the opposite direction from Santa Monica beach. So if you're on a strict budget, and don't mind cramped quarters, a bad view and a lack of creature comforts, the Hotel Carmel puts you at the heart of the action in Santa Monica at a low cost.

Awful experience & below Average Service

by A TripAdvisor Member

Where to begin...

When we checked in we were told that there might not be ANY rooms available because they were quite busy (granted it was Memorial Day weekend, though I had booked our rooms 2 months in advance). Upon finally receiving card keys, we took the elevator to our rooms, only to discover that we had been givenn smoking rooms (even though we asked for non-smoking). If that doesn't sound too bad, listen to this: The travelers accompaning me were given a room with NO TOILET. Yes, no toilet. I immediately called the front desk and was told to come back to the lobby so that we could be assigned new rooms. I was shocked to learn that Hotel Carmel's standard king room means SMOKING, and that they don't have non-smoking rooms for the same price. I was told over and over that if I wanted a non-smoking room I'd have to pay more (not to mention none were available). Talk about discrimination against non-smokers!

Finally, after much heated discussion, we were given a new room...one that faced a bunch of metal equipment which sounded like a train was going by every 30 minutes -- imagine trying to sleep with that noise! No compensation was offered for our troubles, instead we were given glares and the evil eye.

At any rate, I will never stay at this hotel again!

Previous reviews a little unfair....Location Location Location

by A TripAdvisor Member

We stayed here for 5 nights - and although it is not perfect (the rooms are small for a US hotel, TV was a bit fuzzy on some channels, bathroom not huge) - The LOCATION IS THE BEST in Santa Monica, and the rates/rooms reflect this.

Our room was clean and comfortable, and the furniture was brand new! The desk staff were helpful (by European standards) and for $119 per night in this location - the place is a bargain.

Location-wise, I would rather stay here than many of the expensive hotels/spas on Ocean Avenue - but it depends on what you want from your vacation. It is one block from Third Street Promenade, and two from the beach/pier.

Remeber to ask the front desk for your free breakfast voucher (to be used round the corner at the Interactive Cafe)

A very mixed bag

by A TripAdvisor Member

My wife and I stayed here for three nights in August, 2005.

On the positive side: great location (near shopping, good restaurants and the beach, everything you want in a tourist hotel), new furniture throughout (must have been done in the last year or so after some of the negative comments below), comforatable beds.

On the negative side: disco noise (we were on the fourth floor and every night we could clearly feel the bass coming from the disco below), service (the airline had lost our luggage and the hotel staff was a mixed bag. On the one hand they did promise to keep an eye out for our luggage and alert us the moment it came in--it never did--on the other hand they claimed they didn't have replacement toiletries--though they did--and they couldn't return our laundry on the same day--which we desperately needed since we were short on clothes.

One final note, the reviews below are absolutely correct about the staffs disregard about smoking/nonsmoking requests. If this is important to you, make sure that you confirm your request before checking in to your room.

Overall, I'd see if I could get a decent rate elsewhere before I compromised and came here again.

Good location only just compensates

by TripAdvisor Member Ozzykiwi

Arrived at 1.30pm after very long flight from NZ and the guy at the front desk complained that we were early. Even though we were obviously tired, he relentlessly tried to get us on a tour. We paid a deposit for a City Sight / Universal Tour. After a trip in the slowest lift in USA, our room turned out to be very dark and overcrowded overlooking a brick wall and the some huge engineering (presumably the airconditioning) which woke us up a few times during the night. The next morning we asked to be moved to another room, the guy became very petulant and quite rude and eventually gave us another room which was a little nicer and overlooked a tree lined street.

The tour we booked did not have enough seats on the bus, so they refunded our money but said we had to get the deposit back from the Carmel. This turned into a big argument as he kept insisting that he had made it clear the deposit was not refundable. Fair enough if we had changed our minds, but if they couldn't provide the service, the money must be refunded. Eventually he said he would refund the deposit and very ungraciously threw the money back across the counter at us.

I would not stay here again and would only recommend it to people who are not bothered by rude staff and would also recommend you insist on a room not overlooking a brickwall and air conditioning. Great location though, short walk to the beach and pier and very close to a mall and boutique shops.

Santa Monica -- Simply Beautiful!

by volarevolare

When I was planning for my stay in the Los Angeles area, I was offered good advice to check out the Santa Monica area as a place for lodgings.

I was keen to do so, especially since the last time I was in LA, I'd stayed in Anaheim, and didn't really enjoy it.

I'm really glad that Giampiero suggested Santa Monica, and we managed to find a really good deal at Hotel Carmel.

The thing to do is to pick up one of the many free discount booklets and flip to the area you want to stay in, check out the offers, and call them.

For Hotel Carmel, we paid 69.90 per night + tax, so it was a really good deal. Furthermore, it's conveniently located at 2nd Street and Broadway. Right smack in between the beach front and 3rd Street Promenade.

I found Santa Monica clean, pretty and safe. And I really enjoyed our very short stay there.

Also, it's really easy to travel out to various other places as the roads are very easy to navigate with a basic map and all the roads seem to lead out of Santa Monica!!! Or rather, all the roads lead to Santa Monica?

;) We drove to the airport, to Hollywood and all the way to Cabazon too! There are so many restuarants, you just have to take your pick.

I'm so happy that we stayed here! :)

Forum Posts

Hotel Carmel??

by Sapphire695

How is Hotel Carmel for a female traveling alone? Is it a secure enough hotel for a female traveling alone? Is there good security and a lobby area downstairs with a concierge desk? I noticed that it is the least expensive hotel in Santa Monica outside of staying in a "motel".

I find this forum most helpful! Thanks!

Comments

Popular Hotels in Santa Monica

Shutters on the Beach

Hotel Class 5 out of 5 stars

1 Pico Blvd, Santa Monica

Show Prices

The Huntley Hotel Santa Monica

Hotel Class 4.5 out of 5 stars

1111 Second Street, Santa Monica

Show Prices

Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel

Hotel Class 5 out of 5 stars

1700 Ocean Ave., Santa Monica

Show Prices

Georgian Hotel

Hotel Class 4 out of 5 stars

1415 Ocean Ave., Santa Monica

Show Prices

View all Santa Monica hotels

View all Santa Monica hotels

Latest Santa Monica hotel reviews

Holiday Inn Santa Monica Beach At The Pier
59 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 13, 2014
Cal Mar Hotel Suites
239 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 14, 2014
Seaview Hotel
145 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 15, 2014
The Fairmont Miramar Hotel Santa Monica
1060 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 15, 2014
Le Meridien Delfina Santa Monica
155 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 16, 2014
The Huntley Hotel Santa Monica
535 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 13, 2014
Shutters on the Beach
614 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 13, 2014
Embassy Hotel Apartments
1 Review & Opinion
Palm Motel
10 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Dec 13, 2013
Best Western Gateway Hotel Santa Monica
374 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 7, 2014
Sea Shore Motel
394 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 3, 2014
Doubletree Guest Suites Santa Monica
932 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 15, 2014
Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel
1031 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 13, 2014
Hotel Oceana Santa Monica
349 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 8, 2014

 Hotel Carmel

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

Hotel Carmel Santa Monica
Carmel Hotel Santa Monica

Address: 201 Broadway, Santa Monica, California, 90401, United States