Island City House Hotel
Great garden, cosy place
The hotel is a hidden gem.
We booked a suite in the Cigar house and had a wonderful view over the pool and the colonial City House, which is nicely illuminated at night. Very romantic.
Accommodations: large living room with pull-out sleeper sofa, full kitchen, one king bedroom, a bathroom and a balcony overlooking the pool. The place was very clean.
Unique Quality: The hotel’s location, within walking distance of the center of the town is perfect and quiet at night. The staff is friendly. The owners have a few cute well-mannered cats and some of them are descendents of Hemingway’s 6 toed cat.
The continental breakfast is served in the wonderful tropical garden. Great variety of choices.
Bicycles for rent . Nice to explore the rest of the island. We will definitely go back to the Island City House Hotel.
Like a home away from home!
Loved this place! We had a 2 BR, 1 BA suite with small Living Room & Kitchen. But the best part was our porch, with cushioned wicker love seats and rocker! We spent most lazy time out there!
The staff was top-notch. The maid even washed a few dishes we had let in the sink!
Unique Quality: There are several building that make up the Island City House complex and form a 'U' shape. The pool is in the center, along with a lovely brick courtyard where breakfast is laid-out every morning.
Surrounded by trees and fencing, the pool is very private and tropical...just don't let the tiled gator bite your toes!
Directions: Old Town... a few blocks from Duval and a few blocks from the Key West Bight (marina).
We were looking for a special place to stay in Key West for our honeymoon. While the Island City House Hotel could never be considered a "budget inn", we think it gave us great value for our money. It seemed to be within walking distance from nearly everywhere and the accommodations were outstanding. Breakfast was served in the courtyard surrounded by beautiful gardens, We stayed in the third floor suite of a separate building called the "Cigar House". Very private and comfortable.
Note: Price range below is for "Double Occupancy Per Person"
- Atlantis House
- Alexander's Guesthouse
- Key West Bed and Breakfast
- Poinciana Place
- Mermaid & The Alligator
- Speakeasy Inn
- Curry Mansion Inn
- Southernmost Hotel
- Ocean Key Resort
- Hyatt Key West Resort And Marina
Nearby Island City House Hotel
Nearby HotelsSee all 146
Key West Bed and Breakfast 80 feet away
Coconut Grove Guest House 226 feet away
Oasis and Coral Tree Inn 268 feet away
Equator 276 feet away
Curry House Bed and Breakfast 294 feet away
5 Photos of Island City House HotelView Professional Photos
Amenities at Island City House Hotel
- Swimming Pool
Key West Travel Forum
Need advice about Key West, Florida? Visit the Travel Forum for Key West and ask our Answer Gurus.