Garlands Guest House and Creole Cottages

New Orleans

1129 Rue St. Philip, New Orleans, Louisiana, 70116, United States

 

98%

of people enjoy staying here

5.0 our of 5 stars 100 Opinions

Excellent
 
94
Very Good
 
4
Average
 
0
Poor
 
0
Terrible
 
2

Our Members Say

  • jmooreart profile photo
  • Reviews: 2

1 out of 5 starsUser Rating

I'LL NEVER GO BACK!!!!!

I've stayed at the Garlands three times (‘08, ‘09 and Feb ‘11). I loved my first 2 visits, but I will NEVER stay here again...which is really so sad because this place has so much potential.

Our party booked several rooms (more than half of the Garlands was booked by our party). We received terrible service. The toilet in one of the rooms did not flush so we informed Janna about it. She sent her boyfriend in to fix it, he couldn't so she informed us that "these things happen with old houses". Of course they do, but I expected her to get it fixed! The guests in that cottage had to come over to my cottage to use the toilet for several days! Also, the air conditioner leaked causing an entire suitcase of clothing to get soaked. Janna was informed about it but, she offered to do nothing about it. (And of course she did not get the air conditioner fixed!)
The housekeeping service was incredibility lax. There were no towels provided several days of our one week stay. I asked Janna for a bath towel at breakfast and she informed me that they were in the wash - what b&b doesn't have a full supply of towels?!?!? I never did get a clean bath towel that day.

There were only 3 gate openers/remotes that were kept on a table in the courtyard. We had to open the gate with the remote, drive out of the gate, close the gate, run back into the courtyard through the door and replace the remote. This was ridiculous, but we managed until the remotes were not placed back on the table in the courtyard....Janna had them in the house and the house was locked!!!! By the time Janna finally opened the house for us to retrieve the remote, we were late for an appointment!

Breakfast was a joke the garlands advertises a "full gourmet breakfast". We got nothing of the sort!!!! What we had was a continental breakfast - AT BEST!!!!! Example of a morning's breakfast: muffin and yogurt. Another breakfast: ONE pancake!!!! Another: A biscuit and jelly. If you're going to advertise a FULL breakfast, then I expect a full breakfast. If you have no intentions of providing a full breakfast, well, then please don't put that in your advertisement!

Honestly, it saddens me to write such a horrible review. This place is beautiful and has so much potential. If it were run by another manager, I would consider returning. But as long as Janna is there, I can say without a shadow of a doubt that I will NEVER be back!

Unique Quality: It is a beautiful place with so much potential.

  • Opinion of Price: more expensive than average
  • Written March 16, 2011

Was this Garlands Guest House and Creole Cottages review helpful?

  • jmooreart profile photo
  • Reviews: 2

1 out of 5 starsUser Rating

I'LL NEVER GO BACK!!!!!

I've stayed at the Garlands three times (‘08, ‘09 and Feb ‘11). I loved my first 2 visits, but I will NEVER stay here again...which is really so sad because this place has so much potential.

Our party booked several rooms (more than half of the Garlands was booked by our party). We received terrible service. The toilet in one of the rooms did not flush so we informed Janna about it. She sent her boyfriend in to fix it, he couldn't so she informed us that "these things happen with old houses". Of course they do, but I expected her to get it fixed! The guests in that cottage had to come over to my cottage to use the toilet for several days! Also, the air conditioner leaked causing an entire suitcase of clothing to get soaked. Janna was informed about it but, she offered to do nothing about it. (And of course she did not get the air conditioner fixed!)

The housekeeping service was incredibility lax. There were no towels provided several days of our one week stay. I asked Janna for a bath towel at breakfast and she informed me that they were in the wash - what b&b doesn't have a full supply of towels?!?!? I never did get a clean bath towel that day.

There were only 3 gate openers/remotes that were kept on a table in the courtyard. We had to open the gate with the remote, drive out of the gate, close the gate, run back into the courtyard through the door and replace the remote. This was ridiculous, but we managed until the remotes were not placed back on the table in the courtyard....Janna had them in the house and the house was locked!!!! By the time Janna finally opened the house for us to retrieve the remote, we were late for an appointment!

Breakfast was a joke the garlands advertises a "full gourmet breakfast". We got nothing of the sort!!!! What we had was a continental breakfast - AT BEST!!!!! Example of a morning's breakfast: muffin and yogurt. Another breakfast: ONE pancake!!!! Another: A biscuit and jelly. If you're going to advertise a FULL breakfast, then I expect a full breakfast. If you have no intentions of providing a full breakfast, well, then please don't put that in your advertisement!

Honestly, it saddens me to write such a horrible review. This place is beautiful and has so much potential. If it were run by another manager, I would consider returning. But as long as Janna is there, I can say without a shadow of a doubt that I will NEVER be back!

Unique Quality: It is a beautiful place that if run correctly, could be a fabulous b&b!

  • Opinion of Price: more expensive than average
  • Written March 16, 2011

Was this Garlands Guest House and Creole Cottages review helpful?

Write a Review

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

Travelers also viewed

The Place

 

The People

 
Our Members Say
jmooreart profile photo

 It is a beautiful place that if run correctly, could be a fabulous b&b! 

708 members live in New Orleans

 

Questions and Answers

Beamit2me profile photo

Q: 1st visit to New Orleans "In October 2012 my husband and I will have Sat. and Sun. in New Orleans before we cruise on Monday. What are the 'must see' sites..."

TooTallFinn24 profile photo

A: "If I was in N.O. for the first time my list would include; 1) Streetcar- Take the street car from Canal Street along the amazingly beautiful route. Its only $1.25 or..."

Read 5 Replies »
postQuestion_button

Latest New Orleans hotel reviews

Hilton New Orleans / St Charles Ave
221 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 28, 2012
Pontchartrain Hotel
5 Reviews & Opinions
Melrose Mansion
98 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 10, 2012
Clarion Collection Queen & Crescent New Orleans
394 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 27, 2012
Hilton Garden Inn New Orleans
144 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 19, 2012
Cornstalk Hotel
98 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Avenue Garden Hotel
247 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 29, 2012
Ursuline Guest House
182 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 29, 2012
Elysian Guest House B&B
7 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Mar 26, 2012
Maison Dupuy Hotel
649 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Hotel La Salle
10 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jul 23, 2010
Lamothe House
197 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 14, 2012
Nine-O-Five Royal Hotel
25 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 19, 2012
Best Western French Quarter Landmark
138 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 30, 2012