Mayflower On The Park

New York City

15 Central Park West, New York City, New York, 10023, United States

 

66%

of people enjoy staying here

2.5 our of 5 stars 4 Opinions

Excellent
 
0
Very Good
 
1
Average
 
1
Poor
 
0
Terrible
 
1

Our Members Say

  • jelw profile photo
  • Reviews: 303

1 out of 5 starsUser Rating

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Stear clear

Dreadful. Bad room upgraded to worse. Door locks not functioning, things falling apart and filthy!

Unique Quality: The only unique quality is that it is in such disrepair. I do hear it is going to be under new ownership soon though. Hopefully to be either demolished or fully renovated.

  • Opinion of Price: more expensive than average

Was this Mayflower On The Park review helpful?

  • feline01 profile photo
  • Reviews: 708

4 out of 5 starsUser Rating

2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Somewhat affordable park view!!

I needed a large suite following surgery since I'd be spending 3 days in the room and I booked this hotel's suite at a somewhat pricey but not for Manhattan cost of $179.00 a night. The suite was larger than our apartment in New Jersey. The best thing about this hotel for me was that they allow pets so we brought Feline (pronounced Fellini) with us and she spent her 3 days in NYC staring at Central Park. The location is perfect, directly across from Central Park and 1 block north of Columbus Circle where many subway lines verge including the D,F,1, 3 and 9.

Unique Quality: Some rooms are recently renovated and some aren't. Do ask for one that is, we did and I'm glad because even with being recently renovated, the furniture was a bit tatty. I brought some sheets along with me that we covered the sofa with and the top of the bed covering that me and my husband like to refer as a "sKanket", an abbreviation for skanky blanket. The king-sized bed was comfy and there were 2 enormous closets and a small kitchen pantry with a refrigerator and sink. Too bad the hotel didn't go the extra mile and provide a microwave, toaster and/or coffee-maker but there are many places in the area that deliver. I didn't try the restaurant in the hotel called The Conservatory but I read horrible reviews about it. The hotel offers free coffee in the lobby between 6am-7am, why that early, I couldn't tell you. Instead, walk over to Broadway and 62nd and get a fresh brewed coffee and a bagel from any one of the many delis.

  • Opinion of Price: less expensive than average
Mayflower On The Park Photo: Feline gazing at Central Park

Mayflower On The Park Photo: Feline gazing at Central Park


Was this Mayflower On The Park review helpful?

  • whatson profile photo
  • Reviews: 41

1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Mayflower Hotel



Unique Quality: Kind of funky (run down) but for a nicer place you'd have to pay a lot more.

  • Opinion of Price: least expensive

Was this Mayflower On The Park review helpful?

Write a Review

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

More about Mayflower On The Park

I'm always in a New York state of mind...

by feline01

I have a New York City heart and a New Jersey wallet so I live in New Jersey and go to NYC whenever possible. It is a fantastic city with so much to offer. New Yorkers are a strong bunch and nothing can bring them down, only shake them to the core. I watched the towers burn after 9/11 from New Jersey and my husband and I were back having Sunday brunch in the city the following weekend, though it took many weeks before we made our first excursion anywhere below Houston Street. Everyone should visit New York City for something like they've never experienced before. I've seen loads of VT pages on NYC and everyone's impressions were completely different. Some loved the city, others merely like it while a few hated it. And that's the great thing about New Yorkers, they really don't care how you feel about their city. They know it's great and that's all they need to know.

My NYC VT page will not include all the traditional tourist meccas like Empire State, Statue of Liberty etc..You all have heard of them anyway. I will focus on things that people might have overlooked or didn't know about. As for restaurants, I have been a vegan since 2002 and vegetarian since 1996 so almost all of my restaurant picks are suited for the non-dead animal eating public. Or for those who are willing to try a vegetarian meal. I do recommend any of the vegan/vegetarian restaurants for an adventorous carnivore since you might be surprised. The vegetarian selections are astounding, not just beans and rice.

I know this is a travel website but I have to vent here to all the tourists who visit NYC. Ground Zero has become a major tourist attraction, primarily only to people who do not live in NYC or the environs. It is not a tourist attraction, it is an open gravesite even with the "clean-up" ending on 5/30/02. Thousands of people lost their friends and relatives there and I believe it is sickening to visit the site, take photos and gawk. Please respect this graveyard and let the victims' families and friends visit in peace. I know people who visit generally mean well but just the act of getting tickets, waiting on line and taking photos trivializes this tragic event. Plus, seeing sidewalk vendors selling 9/11 memorabilia contributes to the carnival-like atmosphere there. I've driven by and have been sickened. I know there are others who will read this and say I'm crazy, there's nothing wrong with going there to pay your respects. That is true but as I said, many people go there and treat it like a carnival or a "must-see" in NYC.

I have added a few photos that I found of me and my husband on top of the trade center, taken probably around 1999. We had a wonderful day on top of the world, playing backgammon and waiting for the sun to set.

You never know what you will see driving around NYC and we spend alot of time doing so. We followed this truck through the Holland Tunnel from downtown NYC into New Jersey. What an amazing business to run!!!

Feline hasn't had the opportunity to travel with us often but she did get to spend a long weekend with us in NYC in September 2003 while I was recuperating from a medical procedure at the Mayflower Park Hotel. She really did enjoy gazing out the window at Central Park, much more to look at than an apartment parking lot in New Jersey. She was very well behaved so we look forward to taking her on more journeys, especially once the twins arrive.

Travelers also viewed

The Place

 

The People

 
Our Members Say
whatson profile photo

 Kind of funky (run down) but for a nicer place you'd have to pay a lot more. 

7512 members live in New York City

 

Questions and Answers

A16 profile photo

Q: JFK to Morningside Heights "I am arriving at JFK on July 1st (a sunday) around 11 am. Since I'll be alone and with a fair amount of luggage, I was thinking..."

Agraichen profile photo

A: "That's the price I paid on my last trip to NYC. Sunday's are usually lighter, but you never can count on a quick trip from JFK to down town."

Read 4 Replies ยป
postQuestion_button

Latest New York City hotel reviews

Novotel New York
1083 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jun 1, 2012
BRYANT PARK HOTEL
806 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Ameritania Hotel
764 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Trump International Hotel Tower
271 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 29, 2012
St. James Hotel - Times Square
658 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 30, 2012
Intercontinental The Barclay
1560 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jun 1, 2012
Fairfield Inn New York Manhattan/Times Square South
287 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jun 1, 2012
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan / Midtown East
595 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012
Vanderbilt Ymca
229 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 30, 2012
Dream Hotel New York
531 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 27, 2012
Pod Hotel
1329 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 30, 2012
Comfort Inn Manhattan
600 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 30, 2012
Skyline Hotel
716 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Jun 1, 2012
Dexter House Hostel
58 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Feb 18, 2012
Amsterdam Court
504 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 31, 2012