The Plaza

5 out of 5 stars5 Stars

5th Ave at 59th Street, New York City, New York, 10019, United States

21 Reviews

The Plaza Hotel
Enter dates for best prices
Compare best prices from top travel partners
Expedia.com Booking.com Orbitz.com

88%

Satisfaction Very Good
Excellent
58%
406
Very Good
19%
135
Average
10%
72
Poor
5%
41
Terrible
4%
34

Value Score Poor Value

Costs 43% more than similarly rated 5 star hotels

Show Prices

Good For Solo
  • Families78
  • Couples82
  • Solo85
  • Business73
  • cookwv's Profile Photo

    Hotel Under construction

    by

    The hotel was under construction and other than the noise (which was only from 8am-7pm) the hotel was fine. We got discounted rooms for the construction and stayed 1 block from Time Square for less than $100 a night. They put barriers up where the construction occured, so safety wasn't an issue. Great bargain.

    Unique Quality: The hotel is older and made me feel like "Greta Garbo". I felt like I had walked through a time capsule and loved the charm.

    Directions: Time Square was 1 Block.

  • Herkbert's Profile Photo

    Gone but not forgotten

    by

    The Plaza Hotel always held a special allure. It seemed like the place that rich people went to be seen and to show off their status. We cut through the lobby a few times and the string ensemble always seemed to play Eine Kleine Nachtmusik like they knew it was our favorite musical piece.

    When we heard that the hotel was being closed down, we had to stay there before it was gone. It wasn't as glamorous as it probably was in its hey day, but it still was special.

    Alas, it's now gone, but the memory will live on.

    Directions: Right across the street from the South corner of Central park.

  • Hot_Fudge's Profile Photo

    Oysters and champagne..A good Brute will do

    by

    Sleeping naked in silk sheets with oysters and champagne for breakfast:::MMM

    h
    "This is a landmark with international recognition.
    You'd go there because it's a place you'd seen in a movie."

    Tshuva, a scruffy Israeli refugee turned real-estate mogul,
    is expanding his holdings in the United States.
    He bought the 32-story BellSouth building in Jacksonville, Fla.,
    for $91 million, The Gift Building at 225 Fifth Ave. for $125 million
    and converted 21 Astor Place to condominiums.

    But Tshuva is facing resistance from those who want the storied
    hotel to remain unchanged. In answer to these critics, his company's CEO,
    the savvy Miki Naftali, has mounted a publicity campaign to convince residents that
    remaking The Plaza's interior ? while retaining its French Renaissance exterior
    ? is the best way to save it.

    Tshuva actually has history on his side. When The Plaza opened in 1907, it was used
    primarily as a residence for wealthy New Yorkers such as Alfred Vanderbilt. The famous
    flocked to its doors. Alfred Hitchcock shot parts of "North by Northwest" there,
    and it was the site of the Catherine Zeta-Jones/Michael Douglas wedding reception.

    Ernest Hemingway once counseled F. Scott Fitzgerald that he should leave his liver to Princeton and his heart to The Plaza. Just don't forget your luggage ? after April 30, 2005 you probably won't get it back.

  • Hot_Fudge's Profile Photo

    Want to buy a hotel room?

    by

    I think better to describe the surroundings rather than what happened,
    I mean I got a good servicing and the rooms look like something
    you might find in a French Chateau....Mon Dieu..C?st Manifique!

    Unique Quality:
    Just the sort of rooms if you like to play games
    or have a very good imagination
    and like to dress up!

    Directions: End of the park.......

  • Hot_Fudge's Profile Photo

    The Hotel with History

    by

    The weekend stay will go down in my history
    books as one to remember!



    Since 1995, the Plaza has been owned by one of the world's wealthiest men,
    Prince Alwaleed bin Talal bin Abdul Aziz Alsaud of Saudi Arabia, and Millennium &
    Copthorne, a London-based company that runs hotels in 16 countries.
    The prince, a nephew of King Fahd, made headlines after the Sept. 11 attacks when he
    offered to donate $10 million to the City of New York, and Rudolph W. Giuliani,
    the mayor at the time, accepted but then returned the check.

    Mr. Giuliani sent the check back after learning that in a news release,
    the prince had criticized the American government's policies in the Middle East.

    The prince and Millennium & Copthorne paid Donald J. Trump $325 million and
    spent $40 million on renovations. But based on figures from Millennium & Copthorne,
    the Plaza had a pretax loss of $1.8 million last year.

    "It's an icon, but the price is too good to refuse," Kwek Leng Beng, the chairman of
    Millennium & Copthorne, said at a news conference in Singapore, according to
    Bloomberg News. "The prince is very happy - he's invited me to Paris,
    where he wants to give me a big dinner."

    Miki Naftali, president and chief executive of Elad Properties, issued a statement through a
    spokesman, who declined to discuss Elad's plans for the Plaza. A real estate executive
    who had been briefed on the deal said Elad was considering turning some of the Plaza's
    805 rooms into condominiums.

    Mr. Trump talked about the same idea when he controlled the Plaza in the early 1990's.
    He said at the time that condominiums would not turn the turreted French Renaissance landmark into the Manhattan version of a time-share in the Catskills, though some
    architectural historians called the plan heresy.

    "The flavor of the project is similar to what Trump had in mind,
    " the executive who had been briefed on the deal said. "It's going to be a high-end
    condominium with hotel services."

    Unique Quality: h
    "This is a landmark with international recognition.
    You'd go there because it's a place you'd seen in a movie."

    Visitors might remember it from "Plaza Suite," "North by Northwest,"
    "The Great Gatsby" or "The Way We Were."

    Little girls still clamor to have tea in the Palm Court like the fictional Eloise
    who lived in the hotel.

  • Hot_Fudge's Profile Photo

    NY never sleeps, but when u do..here is the place

    by

    I arrived back to my room after a wild night in several clubs
    and an incredible rooftop penthouse party ovelooking Central Park.
    I captured some local wildlife I managed to bag at the rooftop.
    I got all the services I needed after a very long night.
    The bed was very comfy and full marks for bouncy bouncy action.

    HISTORY

    The Plaza was originally built in 1900 and then was rebuilt in 1907
    to the tune of twelve million dollars when the new Ritz Carlton joined
    the other hotels at the turn of the century. The hotel brought elegance
    east of Fifth street. "The opening of the Plaza Hotel was accompanied
    by the sure sign of the automobile on Fifth avenue in New York."

    "The Plaza has been able to maintain its standings over the years.
    The Plaza's various public rooms have undergone numerous incarnations.
    The large room on the corner of Forty-ninth Street and the Plaza,
    which was called simply the "restaurant," assumed various decors as the Edwardian
    Room and the Green Tulop, and the Fifty-ninth Street dining room that served as the office
    of Jules Bache has become, and Remains, the Oak Room."

    "Finally, the Plaza houses New York's one functioning Palm Court, and it has a busy day.
    Breakfasts and salad lunches are served, and no sooner are the last leaves of lettuce
    carried away than a violinist and pianist turn up and a flame is put under the tea kittles and
    cocoa in the kitchens. This does not mean, however, that the Plaza has not plugged ahead
    into the future. Not only does it provide its guests with closed circuit television and choice
    of two movies daily, but troubleshooting hostesses called "service coordinators," together
    speaking all of fifteen languages, patrol the lobby and halls where once private maids and
    lackies scurried obediently."
    h

    Unique Quality: The man at the desk did give me exceptional room
    service and even left a fresh rose on my last night.

    ARCHITECTURE
    The Plaza Hotel, one of New York city's finest hotels,
    was architecturally designed imitating the style of a late medieval
    French chateaux. The elegant lobby contains ornamented archways,
    pillars, and marble floors. This combined with a usage of the color gold
    give the hotel a wealthy, upper-class appearance.

    August 14, 2004
    Eloise Gets a New Landlord: Plaza Sells for $675 Million
    The Plaza's new owner (and thus the new landlord of Eloise,
    the fictional 6-year-old heroine of the children's books by
    Kay Thompson and Hilary Knight) is Elad Properties.
    While the price is not a record for a hotel in New York,
    the per-room price - a measure analysts routinely calculate - is,
    said Sean Hennessey, who follows the New York hotel market for
    Lodging Investment Advisers, a consulting firm.

    Elad is paying $838,509 a room, a sign, Mr. Hennessey said,
    that the hotel market is rebounding from the Sept. 11 terror attacks.
    He said that room rates for hotels in New York had risen 9 percent this year,
    far outpacing inflation.
    PLAZA TO SHUT FOR MAKEOVER

    January 17, 2005 -- Better call the Waldorf, Eloise! —
    The Plaza will be shut down this May for extensive renovations, a new report says.
    "Inquiries about booking special events at the hotel after April are answered with a
    cautionary warning," according to Crain's New York Business.
    "The catering department is advising people not to plan parties at
    The Plaza for May and beyond."

    Directions: Grand Army Plaza, Fifth Ave at 59th St.

  • Graxie's Profile Photo

    Hotel Amenities

    by

    The West Park Hotel is a relaxed urban retreat offering 90 comfortable and quiet guest rooms and suites at a prime location in New York city. The West Park is located on the southwest corner of Central Park, next to Columbus Circle and within a short walking distance from Manhattan's best museums, boutiques, theatres and restaurants

    Unique Quality: Ac
    Children Free
    Concierge
    Cribs
    Drycleaning
    Electronic Room Keys
    Elevators
    Laundry
    Non Smoking Rooms
    Safedeposit
    Security 24 Hour

    Directions: The Holiday Inn is also located in the Harmon Meadow Shopping complex on Plaza Drive just a few hundred meters from the the Courtyard. It is a nice classy hotel with moderate prices

  • deWilde's Profile Photo

    The Way We Were

    by

    My stay there was brief and revolved more around the guy I was seeing who was staying there, as I lived in NYC at the time. The building is beautiful and the view from our room was of Central park, room 1621 as I recall. The plaza is currently closed but scheduled to re-open in 2007 – see below for more info.

    The building is beautiful and grand in stature. You have seen its exterior and interior in more movies than most other Hotels. The lobby is lined with marble and dark wood that oozed class as well as crystal chandeliers. It really is a site to see.

    The staff was welcoming and very helpful. The room we stayed in was small but served its purpose. The bathroom was very nice and the shower was fantastic. I have thick hair so a good shower head makes all the difference. One of the biggest perks of The Plaza is location. You are across the street from Central Park, Tiffany's and other fabulous shopping is but blocks away and if you ever get lost… most people know where it is located.

    The Plaza also offered the Palm Court Restaurant were you could get a spot of tea (traditional high tea) and some finger sandwiches. It’s a Mecca for all little girls that read the Eloise books (drawn by Knight). The Plaza and Palm were her home. For those that have been there you have most likely passed through the lobby and run across Eloise. The painting is being taken care of but I don’t know that she will return at the grand opening.

    From what I understand The Plaza is currently closed for a make-over and partial conversion to condos. This landmark building (1969) will go from 805 hotel rooms to a mere 348 rooms and 200 condominiums. They say that they are keeping the Terrace Room and Grand Ballroom. Both will benefit from an overdue TLC session and should look like new once opened sometime in 2007.

    Unique Quality: Although the new floorplans look like the hotel rooms will face an alley, the condo's will have the Central Park views that the building is know for.

    Directions: If on the subway take the N or R to Fifth Avenue.

  • scottishvisitor's Profile Photo

    Many Many Windows

    by

    We came out of Central Park & there it was a huge hotel - a window cleaners dream or nightmare. We didn't stay here but if we did I would have liked a room with the windows in the roof.

    Directions: Near Central Park

  • kenadams's Profile Photo

    The best!

    by

    The Plaza is known as the best hotel in New York. I have never stayed here so I can't give specific info, but I'm sure its reputation doesn't come out of nowhere.
    You've probably seen it in many movies, from "Breakfast at Tiffany's" to "Home Alone 2". Kings and presidents from all parts of the world have stayed here since the Plaza opened in 1907.

  • vivimero's Profile Photo

    Whao!

    by

    we loved the helpful concierge, the room was excellent and the breakfast simply another world. fresh fruit...great slices of cakes...tea served like in London..
    I really loved to stay there. well, don't use the telephone as they are not cheap but it was not my fault, I had to use it because the mobile company did a mess with me!

    Unique Quality: gym
    whirpool, when working!
    concierge..people that really know!

    Directions: central park!!! everybody knows the Plaza!!!

  • WOW! What a ripoff!

    by

    I spent one night here, and had enought. After seeing it on Home Alone, I thought that it would be a great expreience, but after staying here, I was truly shocked at expensive this place was. In the minibar, you can buy an average can of coke for something like 4 dollars. The staff is great, but most of them just want your generous tips. I got a room with a terrible view. The room is just like any other hotel's, except there is a chandelier in the middle of it. While I would stay here one night just to see how it is, for the next couple of nights I would stay the the Marriott in Times Square and get a suite with the amount of money it costs to get a normal guest room in the Plaza. The Oak Room and the Palm Court, the Plaza's restraunts are also extreamly expensive. While the food is great, you must really need to have a tounge for a few items which are impossible to pronunce.

    Unique Quality: There is no pool, but an overpriced spa which replaced it. While my memory is a bit fuzzy, I do remember that they had a workout room.

  • Dazzle88's Profile Photo

    Live in the Lap of Luxury Type of Hotel

    by

    The is THE hotel. Full of luxury, you dine, sleep, and even shower in the best way possible. With a beautiful view of Central Park this hotel does not come at a "convenient" price, but every penny is worth it! With either a guestroom or a suite you'll definately leave happy! All rooms include flat screen monitors, Internet service, video games (on request) along with MANY other things.

    Unique Quality: Anything you could possibly think of, they have! (or will get for you upon request)...You walk in and its like a fairy-tale!

  • mig7410's Profile Photo

    Your backyard is Central Park

    by

    First class hotel that is somewhat affordable.
    Stroll down Fifth ave., or take a walk in the park.

    Unique Quality: The Oak Room is a classic old Bar.

  • Agraichen's Profile Photo

    Hotel on the Park

    by

    I told my wife I had to go to NYC on business and would be staying at The Plaza. She actually beat me to NY since I had to travel with business partners.

    The Plaza is like what used to be The Ambassador in LA. It is an institution. Just the right amount of snobery, friendliness, and if you're living there, THEY KNOW....

    Unique Quality: The Oak Room is by far one of the more unique character parts/flaws of The Plaza. As a place where you can "be seen without being seen" the service is wonderful and the food, though overpriced is great.

    Directions: Central Park south east corner

More about The Plaza

Forum Posts

MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by califtraveler

Has anyone stayed at or know anyone who has stayed at the Milford Plaza Hotel recently. Have plans on staying there but have read several negative reviews so would like some first hand advice. Thanks for your time.

Re: MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by xymmot

I stayed out there and was not thrilled, but I heard recently that some of the rooms were renovated and almost complete. (read about it in a article last month from a bed bug article but forgot about the particulars) I would not want to stay there if the rooms are more than $125 USD....you get what you paid for and at most I only gave it two stars in my book. Even the Waldorf is getting bad reviews because of the bed bug problems they have. Right now, I would look for the newer hotels and paid the price if I were to stay in NYC Cheers Tommy x

Re: MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by 10028

A tripadvisor poster just reported on the Milford Plaza today:

http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g60763-i5-k4072582-l29806138-Milford_Plaza_Hotel_reopening-New_York_City_New_York.html#29806138

What datse have you reserved the hotel for?

Re: MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by califtraveler

Early April, 2011

Re: MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by 10028

Then you've got plenty of time to look for a better hotel. What made you pick the Milford Plaza in the first place?

Re: MILFORD PLAZA HOTEL; NEW YORK

by zuriga

If you want to stay in that area, I'd look into a hotel called The Time. I used to live near NYC and never needed hotels, but now I come back as a tourist and we tried that hotel a year ago. It is not fancy (same as with the Milford Plaza) but the rooms were fine and the price was a bargain. It's right in the centre of things and it's only one block from the subway, which made it very convenient for getting around and was right near all the theatres. The staff was helpful.

Comments

Popular Hotels in New York City

Casablanca Hotel

147 West 43rd Street, New York City

Show Prices

Library Hotel

299 Madison Avenue, At 41st Street, New York City

Show Prices

The Sherry-Netherland

781 Fifth Avenue, At 59th Street, New York City

Show Prices

Hotel Giraffe

365 Park Ave. South at 26th Street, New York City

Show Prices

View all New York City hotels

View all New York City hotels

Latest New York City hotel reviews

Marriott Marquis New York City
3807 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 20, 2014
Hotel Pennsylvania
4163 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
Embassy Suites Hotel New York City
972 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
Thirty Thirty Hotel New York
450 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
Howard Johnson Express Inn
283 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
Murray Hill East Suites (149 East 39TH Street.)
382 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 19, 2014
Hotel Carter - Times Square District
1675 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 19, 2014
Radisson Lexington Hotel New York
270 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 20, 2014
Comfort Inn Times Square
991 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 13, 2014
Comfort Inn Times Square South
425 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 6, 2014
Fashion 26 - A Wyndham Hotel
1477 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
The Waldorf Astoria
4820 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 21, 2014
Americana Inn
374 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 20, 2014
The Hotel at Times Square
963 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 20, 2014
Millennium Broadway New York
2222 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 19, 2014

 The Plaza

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

Plaza New York City
Plaza Hotel New York City

Address: 5th Ave at 59th Street, New York City, New York, 10019, United States