Pony Island Motel

Highway 12, Ocracoke, North Carolina, 27960, United States
#5 of 14 hotels in Ocracoke
Great (4.0 out of 5.0) 1 review
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
Based on 152 reviews
Enter dates for best prices
Compare best prices from top travel partners


Family Travel Beaches Sailing and Boating
See Amenities
grandmaR's Profile Photo

Offseason in Ocracoke

Great (4.0 of 5.0 stars)
by written on May 24, 2005

Because we were traveling so late in the season, many of the hotels and other accommodations were closed. I called the Bluff Shoal Motel from the AAA book, and they were going to be closed after Thanksgiving to do some renouvations (although they are usually open)

We got to the motel about one o'clock. The office was closed, but there was a sign on the door that said "If you have a reservation, look on the other door". I walked around to the other door and it said,

"Robert Beasley you are in Room 101 and the key is in the door".

There was another notice for someone named Tim

So we went to room 101, and brought the overnight bags in, and Bob put his plant out in the sun. When we got back, the office was open and the lady had a little boy with her, who ran and hid behind his mom when we came in, and checked in. Off season winter rates are $55/night plus about 10% tax.

The pool has been drained and it looks like they are going to put up a new pool deck out of that recycled plastic. They have the same thing at the Pony Pens, but Bob said they've installed it upside down so that the grooves to keep it from being slippery on the bottom instead of the top.

The lady had four restaurants that would be open and she had menus for them.

Unique Quality: SUMMER & HOLIDAYS May 27-Sept. 4
(All with refrigerators & telephones.)

Double or Queen $89.00
Efficiency 99.00

NEW SECTION (Non-Smoking)
(All with microwaves, refrigerators, telephones, wet bar area & coffee maker.)

#101-105, 109 (1 queen) 97.00
#106-108 (2 doubles) 102.00

#201 150.00

(2-room efficiency suite w/whirlpool tub, 1 queen, sleeper sofa & VCR.)
#202-207 (2 queens each) 110.00
#208 (2 rooms w/1 queen, sleeper sofa.) 115.00

#301-302 & 303-304 155.00

(2-room efficiency suites with whirlpool tub, 1 queen, sleeper sofa, VCR's & private balcony.)
#302A & 303A (Lockout rooms) 95.00

Rates do not include state taxes.
Rates are for double occupancy.

Rooms - Additional persons will be $5.00 each for adults and $2.00 each for children under 12.
Luxury Suites - Additional persons will be $10.00 each.

Summer - 5/28 thru 8/19
Spring - 3/1 thru 5/27 Fall - 8/20 thru 11/29
All 4 cottages have central AC/heat, telephone, pool available at motel, outside grill, cable-color TV, microwave, outside shower, linens and docking available.
No paper products or garbage bags are furnished.

PONY ISLAND I (Limited to 6 persons)
3 bedrooms, 1 w/queen, 1 w/double and 1 w/2 twins, 2 baths, large kitchen-dining-living area and screened-in front porch. Ceiling fan in dining area. Located adjacent to Pony Island Motel.
Spring $575 per week, $300 deposit
Summer $850 per week, $350 deposit
Fall $675 per week $300 deposit

"MR. BILLY'S" (Limited to 6 persons)
3 bedrooms, 1 w/queen, 1 w/double and 1 w/2 twins, 2 baths, living room, large kitchen/dining combination, washer/dryer and screened-in front porch. Located on a secluded, sandy lane off of Back Road.
Spring $575 per week, $300 deposit
Summer $850 per week, $350 deposit
Fall $675 per week $300 deposit

Key pickup at Pony Island Motel Office
30 days notice for full deposit refund

Nearby Pony Island Motel

Pony Island Motel

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

  • Pony Island Ocracoke
  • Pony Island Hotel Ocracoke

Address: Highway 12, Ocracoke, North Carolina, 27960, United States

1 Photo of Pony Island Motel

Amenities at Pony Island Motel

  • Restaurant
  • Swimming Pool
  • Free Parking
  • Free High Speed Internet

Ocracoke Travel Forum

Need advice about Ocracoke, North Carolina? Visit the Travel Forum for Ocracoke and ask our Answer Gurus.

Latest Ocracoke hotel reviews

Edwards of Ocracoke
Good (3.0 out of 5.0) 1 Review
The Ocracoke Harbor Inn
Great (4.0 out of 5.0) 2 Reviews
Ocracoke Campground
Best (5.0 out of 5.0) 1 Review
Explore Deeper into Ocracoke