Islander Inn

432 Catawba Ave., Put in Bay, Ohio, 43456, United States
#7 of 7 hotels in Put-in-Bay
Best (5.0 out of 5.0) 1 review
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
Based on 116 reviews
Enter dates for best prices
Compare best prices from top travel partners Travelocity


Water Sports Romantic Travel and Honeymoons Spa and Resort
See Amenities
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices
  • Show Prices

What can we say but a 10

Best (5.0 of 5.0 stars)
by written on May 31, 2011

What a quaint little island who would think you are in Ohio. The Islander Inn made me feel like I was in the Caribbean. The hotel offers everything on the property and walking distance to downtown.

They have a spa, “Isola” is on property, in there adjacent hotel, “The Grand Islander” which was much needed. It offered massages, pedicures, manicures, airbrush tanning, facials. There coffee shop was next to that and my Chai tea latté was in order. I was surprised the selection was so big, with all the specialty coffees and teas you would ever want.

The hotel rooms were redone very bright and fresh. The new mattresses were comfortable and very clean. I liked that we walked out of your room and there were two pools right out our door, when you bring the kids it is very convenient. The one pool has a huge hot tub and felt great when the clouds appeared. The other one had and airplane water fountain with swings hanging outside the bar area. A lot of atmosphere really made us feel like we were on vacation.

You have a nice patio to eat at and can order from several venues and they deliver right on site.

We came with several families and when we wanted to get away from the Mom and Dad roll we went over to the other pool, “Splash” what a blast. They had live music, the biggest swim up bar I have ever seen. Service was spectacular, the bar tenders were unbelievable. To top it off they have a full size Pirate ship for adults only that is a bar. You had a bird’s eye view of the whole party going on from the ship, it really makes for a great atmosphere. There is water around the ship and it purposefully looks dark and dingy to go with the theme. They had full time restroom attendants that kept the entire pool area clean.

That evening it cooled down and we rented the private cabanas with hot tubs in them. What a treat our guests were ecstatic and we had our own little private party with out the mess and maintenance.

Unique Quality: The resort is family owned; the owner Tim purchased a full size real fire truck. He is very humble and hope it is okay to share this, when he grew up his dad was a volunteer fireman and this truck brings back those memories. He was so generous to give our kids a ride around town. The days of individual attention do exist and there isn’t a chain hotel that would have given us this experience. I don’t know what else you would want we couldn’t have asked for more. The Islander Inn was a 10 for us.

Directions: In the heart of downtown

Nearby Islander Inn

Islander Inn

We've found that other people looking for this hotel also know it by these names:

  • Islander Hotel Put In Bay

Address: 432 Catawba Ave., Put in Bay, Ohio, 43456, United States

5 Photos of Islander Inn

Amenities at Islander Inn

  • Swimming Pool
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Bar / Lounge
  • Free Parking

Put-in-Bay Travel Forum

Need advice about Put-in-Bay, Ohio? Visit the Travel Forum for Put-in-Bay and ask our Answer Gurus.

Latest Put-in-Bay hotel reviews

BayShore Resort
Terrible (1.0 out of 5.0) 3 Reviews
Put-In-Bay Resort And Conference Center
Poor (1.5 out of 5.0) 3 Reviews
Explore Deeper into Put-in-Bay