Long Neck Women, Chiang Mai

 
by gdilieto
 
  •   Long Neck Women
    by gdilieto
  •   Long Neck Women
    by Willettsworld
  •   Long Neck Women
    by Willettsworld
  •   Long Neck Women
    by Willettsworld
  •   Long Neck Women
    by Willettsworld
 

32 Reviews of Long Neck Women

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

Write a Review
Cultural Preservation or Human Zoos?
gdilieto profile photo

2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

gdilieto 224 reviews

I asked the taxi driver we had hired for the day whether he knew a village where a Long Neck hilltribe lived. He had just taken us to a Hmong village and I thought it would be interesting checking this other tribe as well. The case was that the guy did know a place and I asked him to take us there. I was a kind of surprised where we entered a gate since villages these days have no longer walls and gates; I noted it was odd and kept going. Then we parked the vehicle and headed to a counter; still a kind of strange since visiting villages should not come for a fee; moreover the ticket was ridiculous expensive for the price standards of the area. Still, I bought the tickets and kept going. Then we walked to what was a main street in a kind of theme park, lined-up with wooden homes in front of which these women were selling art-crafts while basically putting themselves on display for the tourists to snap photos. I snapped few photos myself, then the situation was so odd I started feeling unease and left the place. On our way back I browsed the internet for some more insight and I finally found about the controversy about those "cultural preservation" villages. It is a good business for everyone: for the Administration since those villages boost tourism in the area, for the entrepreneurs who run the villages because of the good revenues and apparently for the tribes as well since they can afford a standard of living they couldn't in their home country by simply putting their women on display. Whatever your view about the controversy, it still makes sense to call these places with their real name: human zoos.

Updated Nov 27, 2011

Was this review helpful?

Long-necked village
Willettsworld profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Willettsworld 8151 reviews
4 more images

I came here, wherever it was, as part of a long-necked tribe daytrip I did from Chiang Mai. We arrived after visiting an orchid farm and riding elephant at the Chok Chai Elephant Camp but things just seemed to be very touristy with lots of souvenir stalls selling tribal arts and crafts and jewellery items. The girls here come from several different tribes but the main one is the famous long-necked Karen tribe so we did the obligatory photo opportunities and I bought a hand-made wooden women figure. Behind the stalls are a few wooden/bamboo houses which were being lived in and indeed the girls were busy doing daily jobs whilst being dressed in traditional tribal clothes but it still seemed to me to be a show for tourists.

Written Nov 28, 2009

Was this review helpful?

Paduang Longneck & Big Ear Village
PS_Lee81 profile photo

4 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

PS_Lee81 120 reviews
living and business
3 more images

After our half day activities at the Chiang Dao elephant camp and lunch, we were bought to this Karen Paduang Longneck & Big Ear village which was about 15 min ride further up Chiang Dao elephant camp.

We were told by our tour guide that we were allowed to take as many photos as we like but in return we should respect their culture as they were... Basically i think this village was built by some proprietors and they find some longneck and big ear hilltribe peoples to live in it. Then in return, they are require to sell the merchandise which bring profit to themselves and also the proprietors. Althought the some part of the village looked like a market place selling the merchandises, but i can still see the rest of the village where built for them to live in.

Our tour guide help us to chat with a young longneck girl who was part of the merchandise seller. She said she was bought to this village a few years ago from somewhere else. She claimed she has a few bro & sis and sadly she can't even remember their face, nor her parents anymore. It was quite a sad story to hear. Most of the longneck people are like refugees with no residenship... they might be born in Thailand, but the government doesn't recognise them, and they have nowhere else to go... The only place they can go is within the village set up by the proprietors... without the ID, they might be caught by the authorities and face the risk of being sent back to Myanmar which they don't really belong to...

Written Aug 29, 2007

Related to:
 Arts and Culture
 Budget Travel

Was this review helpful?

Not the sort of Long Necks (beer) Texans used to.
FlyinFree profile photo

2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

FlyinFree 8 reviews

The trip to the Long-neck village was high point of our trip. It's not for the elderly or handicapped though. It is a very narrow path winding its way into a valley where the long neck people live. Then, there is the even more difficult trek back out of the valley. Definitely a difficult trek for those out of shape. Well worth it if you're up to it. Great photo ops with long neck women and children. Of course, lots of souvenirs to be bought too.

Written Jul 18, 2007

Related to:
 Arts and Culture
 Hiking and Walking

Was this review helpful?

Mae Hong Son
venteeocho profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

venteeocho 542 reviews

Mae Hong Son, Thailand's northern border city, hiding itself in between the towering mountains with densely forested slopes, stretching to the Burmese border. Mae hong son is known for its charm of scenery and culture. The people of Mae Hong Son consists of the Shans who live in the city and the hilltribe people who live in remote villages on mountain tops where elements of lifestyle have changed little in hundreds of years. The city is covered with the mist all year long. Mae Hong son gains its nickname of "the City of Three Mists" from the fact that it has dewy mist in the winter, forest fire mist in the summer and rainy mist in the rainy season.

Then continue to "long-neck" or "giraffe tribe”. But the women who wear these brass rings on their neck belong to a sub-group of the Karen known as the Padaung. There are other sub-groups who do not and never have practiced this custom. A further myth is that these rings act to elongate the wearer's neck. Any chiropractor or orthopedic surgeon will tell you that this would lead to paralysis or death. In fact the appearance of a longer neck is a visual illusion. The weight of the rings pushes down the collar bone, as well as the upper ribs, to such an angle that the collar bone actually appears to be a part of the neck!

Written May 31, 2007

Related to:
 Study Abroad
 Hiking and Walking
 Singles

Was this review helpful?

Smiling with their long necks and Puma outfits
Anita_Porec profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Anita_Porec 345 reviews
I love it.
4 more images

They look exotic regardless of their Puma sweatshirts and Diesel flip flops.
Ask before you take pictures.
Bring gum or crayons for the kids - they will smile on your pictures.

Save your money and buy your souvenirs here. Help the locals a little.

Story goes.... a long time ago when they were still many tigers alive, they ate people.
Men were given guns and woman were given neck rings so the tiger doesn't have such an easy time biting their head off.
Fair.

Updated May 16, 2007

Related to:
 Arts and Culture
 Eco-Tourism

Was this review helpful?

A human zoo or just poor people needing help ?!
Fernandocramos profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Fernandocramos 172 reviews
4 more images

A lot of theories exist about the use of necklaces by Karen longneck women. Some say it was to protect of tigers attacks when they were still in Burma others say they continues using it just to continue to win a change (only middle of survival that they possess) in detriment of their health, because to prolongate the neck, the bones of the thorax go down harming their health.
They say that if tourists don't visit them anymore, they would be forced to remove the necklace and to stop with that mutilation. But what would happen to that tribe? Would they suffer without government help?
The answer still is not known, nor what is right or wrong.
It fits to you to decide if you should go there or not.

Updated Apr 24, 2007

Was this review helpful?

Pay attention with your gifts.
Fernandocramos profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Fernandocramos 172 reviews
4 more images

I read some reviews talking about give to the children some gifts when visiting the tribe.
I though it would be many childrens so I bought some stickers and gave it to them.
They didnt know what to do with it, and sometime later whem I look back, I could saw this image.

Updated Mar 28, 2007

Was this review helpful?

The touristy way to see the long necks
Mr.Sparkle profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Mr.Sparkle 327 reviews
a long neck at work
4 more images

You can visit a hill tribes village where there are several different types of minorities living together. It is a rather touristy, and expensive place to go, but if you can’t make out to see the real thing than this is your only option. The most exciting thing here is the long necks. Entrance price is 500 bath. Be weary of most goods that are for sale in the shops inside the village. Some or non authentic, poor quality or made from inferior material.

Written Feb 24, 2007

Was this review helpful?

Karen Long Neck Women
imstress profile photo

4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

imstress 1973 reviews
Karen Long Neck Gal
4 more images

We travelled all the way from Mai Sai to Pa Dong to visit the Karen Long Neck Women. Our tour guide said that this is a real Long Neck Women Village. There were 2 other tribes residing in the same area.

The brass ring on the neck is not individual accumulated rings on the neck but a brass spiral coil that goes around the neck. The coil on the neck can be taken out and the life of the women will not be die immediately once they remove the coil.

Two ladies have their coil remove and examined and x-ray by doctors and they did not die and has proven the myth wrong.

The brass coil are indeed very heavy. I had them on for a min and will not choose to wear it for the rest of my life.

Updated Jan 9, 2007

Address: Pa Dong, Mae Hong Son

Related to:
 Arts and Culture
 National/State Park

Was this review helpful?

Top 3 Hotels in Chiang Mai

Rimping Village  Chiang Mai

 1 Review and 528 Opinions  Perfect - hotel, people, service, food, room EVERYTHING, highly recommend - LOCATION LOCATION... 

 Hotels in Chiang Mai

Golden Cupids Hotel  Chiang Mai

 2 Reviews and 112 Opinions  I was met by courtesy transportation laid on by the hotel at Chiang Mai airport and on arrival at... 

 Hotels in Chiang Mai

Mandarin Oriental Dhara Dhevi  Chiang Mai

 2 Reviews and 282 Opinions  Everything you would expect from a Mandarin Oriental plus the really spectacular design. Two... 

 Hotels in Chiang Mai

The Place

Long Neck Women

Long Neck Women tips and photos posted by real travelers and Chiang Mai locals.

  Write a Review  
Experience Chiang Mai
 

The People

106 Members Live Here
 
Our Members Say
 profile photo

 We travelled all the way from Mai Sai to Pa Dong to visit the Karen Long Neck Women. Our tour guide said that this is a real Long Neck Women Village. There were... 

106 members live in Chiang Mai

 

Questions and Answers

Kemack profile photo

Q:  Hello VT , does anybody know a nice guesthouse with a/c in the old city for 350 to 450 baht ? . I would like the opinion of those... 

sydneystone profile photo

A: see tripadvisor.com for reviews 

Read 4 Replies

postQuestion_button

Top Chiang Mai Writers

1

Chiang Mai

SumTingWong profile photo

 Smoke from inscents swirl around the nose, travel through the body until it reaches the depths of the heart. The chanting of monks can be heard in the distance. Bells from the monasteries chime in the... 

2

VISITING COUNTRY THAILAND - CHIANG MAI

balhannah profile photo

 Chiang Mai is Thailand's northern capital, and is quite popular with tourists and also Thais. A short flight from Bangkok and I arrived in Chiang Mai. The countryside looked quite pretty from the...... 

3

Chiang Mai Trip 2005: Wed 4th May - Sun 8th May

DarkRay profile photo

 The introduction of budget airlines in Singapore opens up a whole new possibilities for short trips out of the country. In February 2005, Tiger Airways, the budget carrier operated by Singapore... 

4

Chiang Mai

Gili_S profile photo

 Chiang Mai is a great place to base your location when you want to experience the wonderful opportunities in Thailand with all of it amazing places, nature, culture, food and more. 

5

Jungle Trek and Elephant Ride in Chiang Mai

vigi profile photo

 Wanna experience my jungle trek? Check out my TRAVEL JOURNAL  

View all rated pages

View newest pages

Build your own Chiang Mai page

Travel Editors for Chiang Mai

xaver profile photo