There are good places to shop all over the island with good deals to be has in Coxen Hole and in some of the smaller shops in West End.
West Bay shops and the ones at the resorts are a bit higher in price but they just about always carry a large selection of sizes and colors.
What to buy: You can find good deals on swim suits and local wood carvings.
What to pay: Remember that in West End the asking price is normally double of what you can get it for but remember that the folks selling the items have to make a living on what you spend.
The La Iguana have more selections of local t-shirts in general. The regular prices at other booths are $10.00 per t-shirt.
Not sure how these items come here when there are no Mayan ruins here. These are probably to add to the nice gifts to bring home from your trip.
There is a store that only sells native art. There are woven hats, woven purses, woven shoulder bags, embroidered aprons, etc.
Along the waterfront pier there were some little shops set up to sell gods. They had lots of bits and peices of everything. We couldn't resist buying a hammock!!