We found some very interesting items at Jake's. There was a small building with many items for gifts or for yourself. I bought a photo frame with a streamertail hummingbird on one side. I really liked it. We also bought postcards, and some other gift items.
What to pay: I preferred shopping at the small hotel gift shops because there you are not hassled into buying things like you are on the streets. You pay what it is marked and do not have to haggle.
Stanley sets up his 'shop' over by the buntwood tree in Treasure Beach. He'll have interesting wood carvings, necklaces, calabashes, etc...pretty standard things, but he's a wonderful man to purchase from.