Everyone that goes to Guana Cay always ends up at Nippers pub but personally I like Grabbers Pub and Grill because it is smaller, more relaxed and not hectic. It has some different games you can play and the beach although tiny is gorgeous and it has hammocks. The area is secluded and the crowed is friendly. Grabbers in my opinion the place to go on Guana for a relaxing time.
Nippers offers some great dishes and for decent prices. It is about a 10 minute walk from the ferry dock and it is one of the more popular bars around. A late middle aged crowd of locals drinks at this spot during the day while the place fills up during the nights and on Sundays. The food is good quality and the beers are a standard 5$ each. Nippers is painted in all different colors and it has its own impressive two level swimming pool with the pirate logo on the bottom of the pool. It also has a gift shop selling shirts with Nippers on them and the bar is large enough to hold a few hundred people at least. Good times.
Favorite Dish: I really like any of the platters as well as the chicken sandwich with hot sauce, delicious.