The Hotel 1829 restaurant is on Government Hill. It serves classic dishes and is expensive- but well worth it if you want a special night out. The food is spectacular as is the service. They had both 100 year-old and 150 year-old Grand Marnier which I tried. The smoothness of it was unbelievable! I havent been there for a few years so I would check out the latest menu if you decide to go. Definately look into it.
Hands down the best restaurant on the island that we have found so far is Agave at Point Pleasant resort. The view is spectacular, the service is excellent, and the food is superb. Watching the full moon rise over the Drake passage will melt the most hardened cynic.
Favorite Dish: Key Lime Pie. The entrees are excellent, but the pie is to die for.
the terrace resturaunt at bluebeards is the place for romantic fine dining!!! your veiw is all of the charolette Amali harbor! and all of the glistening lights on the hillsides surrounding the harbor...very tropical, very beautiful spot!