Au Sergent Recruteur, Paris

3 out of 5 stars 5 Reviews

41, Rue Saint Louis en L'Ile 01 43 54 75 42

Been here? Rate It!

  • Not bad from outside
    Not bad from outside
    by mariev
  • Au Sergent Recruteur
    by Radiomom
  • Au Sergent Recruteur
    by Azhut
  • Le Sergent Recruteur: Totally new owners and menu!

    by KarenT37 Written Nov 1, 2012

    The old Taverne Sergent Recruteur was gutted and has now re opened as Le Sergent Recruteur. The chefs (French and British) have moved back from a Michelin starred run in London and bring that expertise to the new menu. It's a whole new experience and one that is worth repeating.

    Was this review helpful?

  • mariev's Profile Photo

    Au Sergent Recruteur: Tourist trap or restaurant ?

    by mariev Updated Mar 15, 2010

    4 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Not bad from outside

    Should I put this under tourists traps or restaurants ? or under"things to do" (for masochists that is)

    I always kept hearing bad things (like : no parisian in his/her right mind would go there) about this place and was never interested in eating there, but a visiting friend (whose name and nationality will be kept secret – he has been punished enough for inflicting this upon us) got a recommendation from a friend’s friend and we decided to see if this was really SOOOOO BAD !!!…

    At any rate, SABENA ! (no not the defunct airline but Such A Bad Experience Never Again).

    To make a long story short, if you want gatronomy, better go to McD (at least it’s cheaper) or the RU (university cafeteria) (that’s gastronomy when you compare).

    The restaurant is more than noisy, invaded by bus groups and brit stag nights (we were 2 lost frenchies among some 80 people), and if you add the ‘drink all you can’ option, you get the picture…

    About the food (only one fixed price option : 45 Euros, wine and beer included (unnamed wine - better keep it unnamed (but you have to pay for water)) : huge plates (starters are ‘all you can eat’), gross, overcooked meat, industrial bread, rare greasy vegetables swimming in a fat bland sauce or served raw in a basket… BEURK! (in English : Yuck!) - I know, the concept is supposed to be a "gargotte", but...

    The setting (Ile Saint Louis) and the deco are interesting and some people seemed even to LOVE the ambiance (to each his/her own tastes, if you are a drunken rugbyman, it may be your style)……..(and if you like this type of place, you have "Nos Ancetres les Gaulois nearby (i didn't go there since my student's years but it is said unchanged, same style, same price).

    Favorite Dish: Perhaps the bread ... (they don't do it themselves it seems)
    The tap water is acceptable

    Was this review helpful?

  • Au Sergent Recruteur - Paris: Great Service

    by MikeM2 Written Nov 29, 2009

    2 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    I love this place - I first went in September 1964 - enjoyed the style. decor and ambience of the restaurant and found the way they serve enjoyably different from the norm.

    (the nearest, similar in style is Durgin Park in Boston - 1992 visit) but I digress...

    On a visit to Paris in early 1990 with my schoolboy 'I want to be an architect' son I decided to take him there so he could see the interior design

    The maitre d' stopped us at the door - do you have a reservation ?

    Sorry - no!

    'Désolée' - he replied with the most pronounced Gallic shrug I have ever see

    So I explained my wish for my "architect" son to see the interior as I remembered it from my first visit in '64 - Would it be ok - just to look inside ??

    Ah-ha - you have been here before - I nodded - Well for such regular clients we always keep a table in reserve ...

    My teenage son was most impressed .. but I suggest you all book as I will do next time

    The location is only a few minutes walk behind Notre Dame

    Was this review helpful?

  • Radiomom's Profile Photo

    Au Sergeant Recruiter: Meet other Diners, and ALL you can Drink!

    by Radiomom Updated Jul 14, 2003

    1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    SERGEANT RECRUITER 41 rue St Louis-en-l'Isle is a fixed prix menu in an ancient setting. As a pair, you'll get to know your neighbors -- huge baskets of crudities, cheese, sausages, breads are 'shared.' We met a nice couple from Germany whose English was far better than our German. House red or white wine as much as you need (could be dangerous for a few friends of mine back home!).

    Was this review helpful?

  • Azhut's Profile Photo

    AU SERGENT RECRUTEUR: A romantic place for a special date

    by Azhut Written Jun 15, 2003

    3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Confortable place with good cookin and wonderful dishes. Typical french taste and good music. You'll enter in a lillte heaven with every kind of deliciuos.

    Favorite Dish: Every typical French dish is great, You only have to choose!!

    Related to:
    • Trains
    • School Holidays

    Was this review helpful?

Instant Answers: Paris

Get an instant answer from local experts and frequent travelers

116 travelers online now

Comments (1)

  • Feb 12, 2013 at 1:33 PM

    Been there MANY times and have ALWAYS enjoyed it. Now the last time I was there was in March of 2003. So if the changes took place after that then I will have to wait until I go back to have a true opinion.

View all Paris hotels