CLOSED - Alice's Restaurant, Key West

4.5 out of 5 stars 5 Reviews

1114 Duval Street Key West, Florida 33040 305-292-5733
  • Key Lime Pie with Chocolate Crust at Alice's
    Key Lime Pie with Chocolate Crust at...
    by Sunshine64
  • CLOSED - Alice's Restaurant
    by jelw
  • Inside Alice's Restaurant
    Inside Alice's Restaurant
    by Sunshine64

Been here? Rate It!

  • sunlovey's Profile Photo

    Alice's Restaurant: Fantastic food, good atmosphere, fun staff

    by sunlovey Updated Apr 4, 2011

    4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    ?Where Fabulous Food and Fun Times Meet?
    That's Alice's motto... and it's true, we had a blast when we ate here, the food was truly mouthwatering and the atmosphere was a lot of fun...It's one of those places that serves up food that you will completely relish. With nice presentation and exquisite taste. A lot of the restaurants you encounter in Key West seem to cook for the drunken masses, assuming your inebriated state will dull your sense of taste... not Alice's, it's quite well thought out and tasty cuisine.

    Favorite Dish: I had:
    Spicy Pink Vodka Conch Bisque, Finished with Stolichnaya Vodka
    Macadamia Coconut Nut Crusted Shrimp
    Honey Wasabi, Papaya Ginger Chutney and Coconut Rice

    Our group shared one of every dessert on their menu....mmmmm!

    beautiful presentation of desserts

    Was this review helpful?

  • jelw's Profile Photo

    Small Chef at Large: Alice is now Catering

    by jelw Updated Mar 7, 2010

    3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    The following is taken from Alice's website;
    Chef Alice Weingarten's
    Accomplishments and Accolades

    November 2003
    North America Restaurant Association

    Five Star Award of Excellence Recipient

    April 2003 Distinguished Restaurants of North America (DiRona) Award Winner

    October 2001 Made Honorary Faculty Member Distinguished Visiting Chef
    by Johnson & Wales University
    North Miami Florida Campus

    Zagat 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004
    Award of Excellence

    August 2001 Chosen as one of South Florida’s Seven Top Hotel Chefs
    By South Florida Gourmet Magazine

    July 2000 “Hemingway Birthday Dinner” at the
    James Beard Foundation in Manhattan, New York

    Fodors 2000,2001,2002, 2003 Fodors Choice

    March 2000 Inducted into the James Beard Foundation

    January 2000 Chosen by South Florida Gourmet Magazine
    as one of the Top Ten Chef’s in South Florida

    August 1999 Chosen as the Chef of the Month by South Florida Gourmet
    Magazine for the month of August

    Bon Appetite Magazine, Alice’s food is described as a “New World Fusion Confusion” of whimsical Asian, Mediterranean and Caribbean creations with her mother’s meat loaf thrown in for good measure. Key West the Newspaper reported that “if you want wonderful food beautifully presented in a pleasant atmosphere by congenial staff, it’s a promise fulfilled at Alice’s.”

    Chef Alice's Key West

    Was this review helpful?

  • grandmaR's Profile Photo

    CLOSED - Alice's Restaurant: CLOSED - James Beard Recognized Chef

    by grandmaR Updated Aug 29, 2014

    3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    The restaurant is very dark inside so it was hard to take photos. There were three-D clouds on the ceiling, and nice tablecloths on the tables with leopard print under-clothes. The waiters were all very correct. It is a very upscale place with very nice food and wines.

    Favorite Dish: This is much more expensive than we normally have. They gave us 3 crackers with seeds on it and butter to begin with.

    First, we had a "small plate" which was billed as hearts of palm. The heart of the palm tree is the growing tip, and eating it kills the tree. Since the cabbage palm (now called the Sabal palm) is the state tree of Florida, this is now illegal, and I wanted to see what it tasted like. It was really roasted green chilies con queso (cheese sauce) for dipping chips into - two kinds of chips - one was a blue corn tortilla chip which I thought was green in the very dim light, and the other was wonton wafers (like the chinese noodles they give you to dip into mustard or marmalade sauce but square). I only felt one thing in the cheese that might have been a palm sliver. Bob didn't eat any because he didn't want to chance the cheese (he's lactose intollerant), plus he had hearts of palm during survival training and didn't want to repeat the experience.

    Then I had a Flavors of Fall salad which had figs, candied walnuts, golden raisins and English Stilton blue cheese in various different kinds of greens. Bob had Southwestern blue crab appetizer which came in a Chinese takeout dinner box with Chinese mustard and green chili rangoons. He said it cleared out his sinuses. Both of these were $8. None of these things were an entree as the entrees ran from $14 to $30 each.

    I did have milk and dark chocolate mousse cake with a crispy peanut cookie crust for dessert. We drank water. The total was $40.80, plus $1.50 for parking at a meter.

    Alice's inside Specials menu Small plate Dark chocolate mousse cake Doorway to Alices

    Was this review helpful?

  • ksfmom's Profile Photo

    Alice's Restaurant: A Fabulous Find on Duval Street

    by ksfmom Updated Apr 4, 2011

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    After a long day of traveling, our dinner at Alice's was a much-needed respite from the hectic day getting to Key West.

    We walked here after taking in the sunset at Mallory Square. We didn't have reservations, but were seated immediately. Before long, the whole place filled up. The interior is very cozy in an elegant sort of way. Presentation was very creative e.g. plates were served from what looked like a large pie rack carried by waiters. Service was impeccable; waiters were always there without being obtrusive. Every item we ordered was excellent and drinks were on the strong side (that's good!).
    This was one of our favorite dining experiences while in Key West.

    Favorite Dish: Fresh shrimp served on a bed of coconut rice was very husband had the seared tuna...also very good. We didn't save room for dessert, but they looked wonderful. A shopkeeper told us if we went back to try the Palmtinis (I hope I have that right)...Alice's version of a Cosmopolitan. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

    Was this review helpful?

  • Sunshine64's Profile Photo

    Alice's Restaurant: Amazing Salad

    by Sunshine64 Updated Apr 4, 2011

    2 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    We stopped in to Alice's for a late lunch (so late that the kitchen was almost closed but they agreed to serve us - since we were 7).

    The decor is modern/island, and you can read all about Alice and her restaurant-ing past in the articles in the hallway to the bathroom.

    While we were there several calls for dinner reservations came in - one asking if they could have the fish they caught prepared - something we found Alice's will do, if they're not too busy.

    Favorite Dish: I will often exaggerate and say I had the best XYZ of my life, but I have to tell you, this salad really was the best - the Pure Passion Salad. Outstanding!

    One of my friends got the Brazilian Samba Salad, and he cleaned his plate, too.

    We had Alice's Key Lime pie (which has been featured in Southern Living Magazine), which was an interesting twist with a chocolate crust.

    Inside Alice's Restaurant Key Lime Pie with Chocolate Crust at Alice's

    Was this review helpful?

Instant Answers: Key West

Get an instant answer from local experts and frequent travelers

31 travelers online now


View all Key West hotels