CLOSED - Upper Crust Pizzeria, Key West

5 out of 5 stars 3 Reviews

611 Duval Street 305-293-8890

Been here? Rate It!

  • The Upper Crust Pizzeria
    The Upper Crust Pizzeria
    by 850prc
  • Upper Crust waiting area
    Upper Crust waiting area
    by 850prc
  • Upper Crust: Best "After the Bars" Pizza!

    by rockycomfort Updated Feb 19, 2009

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    The mates on the fishing boats all told us to hit Mr' Z's pizza after that final 3am beer...They gotta try Upper crust! Maybe the name or location right on Duvall scares 'em off, but we tried both more than once...Upper Crust wins by a pie. Crunchy crust, fresh ingredients, this would be good pizza even in NYC or Chicago.

    Related to:
    • Family Travel
    • Budget Travel
    • Food and Dining

    Was this review helpful?

  • Upper Crust: Best pizza in Key West

    by SpiralJacobs Written Aug 7, 2007

    Stopped in to Upper Crust for a late night snack. The pizza is excellent, very thin crispy crust with fresh toppings. Not a fancy place, just an average pizzeria with above average pizza.

    Favorite Dish: The leaf spinach topping was very fresh and delicious.

    Was this review helpful?

  • 850prc's Profile Photo

    The Upper Crust Pizzeria: Some of the best pizza ever

    by 850prc Updated Aug 5, 2006

    4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    This was excellent pizza. I personally believe that the secret was the Neopolitan style crust, and the excellent blend of ingredients. In addition to pizza, they also serve salads and calzones. I see by my pamphlet that they also deliver, something I wish I'd known. :)

    They have a huge selection of toppings for their pizzas, including:

    baby clams
    baby shrimp
    bacon and canadian bacon
    grilled chicken
    italian sausage

    buffalo mozarella

    And if you are or are buying dinner for a beloved vegetarian, check out the veggie offerings:
    jalapeno peppers
    black olives
    sliced onions
    sliced peppers
    fresh basil
    fresh garlic
    roasted red peppers
    diced tomatoes
    sliced tomatoes
    portabello mushrooms
    sun-dried tomatoes

    Favorite Dish: Well, it's the pizza. We had a "Truman", which was a perfect combo of hamburger, sliced pepperoni and sausage. We had the LARGE, which is $18.95. A SMALL, which WOULD have been enough for three, is $14.95.

    Among other interesting speciality pizzas:

    The Whitehead - portabello mushrooms, sundried tomatoes and freshly chopped garlic

    The slightly pesto - white pizza splashed with pesto, fresh garlic and fresh diced tomatoes

    The Roosevelt - fresh buffalo mozarella, fresh basil leaves, sliced tomatoes and fresh garlic

    The Uncommon - bacon, fresh pineapple, and jalapenos.

    The Upper Crust Pizzeria Upper Crust waiting area

    Was this review helpful?

Instant Answers: Key West

Get an instant answer from local experts and frequent travelers

29 travelers online now


View all Key West hotels