Favorite thing: Before you head out to Amish Country, you might want to have a look at the online visitors guide which you can print out before leaving home. You can also pick one up once you get to Shipshewana, we saw them at Mennohof and I imagine they have them at other locations as well.
Favorite thing: Take a walk around town. Hostetler's is the largest of the remaining historic structures. Morton Street contains an eclectic grouping of stores, shops, and houses, catering to the visitors every interest. Arts, woodworking, sweets, baked goods, and a vew B&B's dot the street. Even in you're not into shopping, this is a pleasant respite from the turn of the previous century.