El Milagro, Brooklyn
This shop has wondeful artwork, jewelry (nice amber!), a wide variety of gifty items, and there are even some pieces of furniture. Lots of wall-hangings, too!
The colors are gorgeous, and while the prices are painful for a thrifty person like me...they aren't outrageous.
What to buy: I think the jewelry is especially unique and interesting.
What to pay: Better than Manhattan or Smith Street, that's for sure.