McSorley's Ale House, New York City

  McSorley's Old Ale House in East Village
by Jefie
 
  • McSorley's Old Ale House in East Village
      McSorley's Old Ale House in East Village
    by Jefie
  •   McSorley's Ale House
    by Peterodl
  •   McSorley's Ale House
    by Peterodl
  •   McSorley's Ale House
    by Peterodl
  •   McSorley's Ale House
    by Peterodl
 

21 Reviews of McSorley's Ale House

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful

Write a Review
McSorley's Ale House: McSorley's Golden Rule: "Be good or be gone!"
goodfish profile photo

4 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

goodfish 919 reviews
This is the place!
2 more images

This was The Husband's favorite bar. McSorley's Old Ale House has the distinction of being NYC's oldest continually operating saloon - and it looks it. From sawdust-strewn floors to memorabilia-covered walls to potbellied stove, very little has changed since its establishment, in 1854, by enterprising Irishman, John McSorley. This is the real deal - Abraham Lincoln drank here, for cryin' out loud! It was the traditional working man's bar: off-limits to women until 1970 and only then opened opened its doors to the Fairer Sex, to much hue and cry, after being sued for discrimination. In fact, one of their mottos was "Good ale, Raw Onions and No Ladies".

You come here for one thing: ale. Do not ask for beer and don't request a tap list as there are only two kinds: dark cream stock ale and light lager, and you get two mugs of foamy for under a fiver. Yessiree, as insanely cluttered as the walls may be, they're into austerity when it comes to everything else: cash only, no barstools, no sports TV and no music. There are, however, tables along the back to rest those tourist-weary feet while you polish off your brews.

In fine 1800's style, a couple of chalkboards list their Bill of Fare - short but blessedly cheap for cash-strapped travelers. The cheese plates, with onions and hot mustard, are a great accompaniment to the ales. Don't like ale? They offer a couple of sodas but I'm guessing if you don't have a passion for the pint, you won't go here anyway.

This is not a place for your Sunday Best and it's absolutely packed, loud and crazy at night so come in the afternoon if you don't like Close Encounters of the Schnockered Kind. And be warned - they'll keep bringing you fresh rounds until you tell them to stop!

Dress Code: You've got to be kidding.

Updated Apr 2, 2011

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Related to:
 Study Abroad
 Budget Travel
 Beer Tasting

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Old Ale House: History in a pint!
Jefie profile photo

4 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Jefie 1601 reviews
At McSorley's Old Ale House in East Village
1 more image

McSorley's Old Ale House dates back to 1854, which makes it the oldest continuously operated watering hole in New York City. When it opened, it was mostly known as an Irish worker pub, a place where the new immigrants could gather in a friendly atmosphere to drink a few pints after work. I guess the most surprising thing about McSorley's is that not much has changed since its humble beginnings - we were there for Happy Hour and saw plenty of people walk in with their business suits on and place their order while getting rid of their tie! It's not a big place and it's very popular, both with tourists and locals, so make sure you get there early if you want to grab a table. Otherwise, you can always stand at the counter or share a table with another group of people, which always makes for fun conversations. You can only get beer at McSorley's, with a choice between bitter or stout (pale or dark). The half-pints are 2 for $5, and most customers won't hesitate to order 4, 6 or 8 pints at a time. Service is not particularly friendly, but the atmosphere of the place - which doesn't seem to have changed in the last 100 years or so - totally makes up for it.

Dress Code: Casual

Updated Apr 26, 2010

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: 212-473-9148

Website: http://www.mcsorleysnewyork.com

Related to:
 Beer Tasting

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: McSorley's
Peterodl profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Peterodl 229 reviews
4 more images

Started in 1854, McSorley's is the oldest continuously operating bar in New York City. Walking into the bar is to step back in time. The old wood and sawdust on the floor assault you with the faint smells of history. Everyone from Abe Lincoln to John Lennon have frequented McSorley's.
Women could only get as far as the potbellied stove in the middle of the front room before being escorted back outside up until 1970. The front and back rooms are covered with memoralbelia, photos, comments from visitors (I saw Bill Clinton's thanks) and old newspapers. As long as you observe the motto "Be Good or Be Gone" carved into the bar, you'll enjoy McSorley's.
The only drink to choose from, ale, comes in either light or dark and is served in two glasses instead of one large glass.

Written Aug 25, 2008

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Website: http://www.mcsorleysnewyork.com/home.html

Related to:
 Budget Travel
 Road Trip
 Backpacking

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: One of New York's Most Historic Bars
Paul2001 profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Paul2001 1665 reviews
The Entrance into McSorley's
1 more image

McSorley's Ale House is one of the most historical bars in Manhattan. It was opened in 1854 and feels it. Obviously the owners go to a grea degree to make sure that the bar looks like it did in the mid-19th century with special attention paid to decor and furniture. The beer in here is cheap with a half-pint costing $2.00. The clientele is most students from the nearby University of New York and tourists. It is well worth dropping by for a brief drink but after a while you sense a tourist trap of sorts.

Dress Code: casual

Updated Jan 5, 2008

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: Simply the best pub I have been to in a long time!
mbsimjam profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

mbsimjam 125 reviews

McSorley's is the personification of atmosphere. If there was ever a pub that seemed to jump on a ship at the harbour in Belfast and hitch a ride to New York, this is it. And they combine the irish culture (not like the irish wannabes named Finnigan's and Finn McCools, etc..that you see in every city in North America) with their pride of being New Yorkers to make it into a place you are actually proud to drink in. The barmen and cooks are all irish...their accents prove it.

It is one of the best pubs I have ever been to. And the beer is simply fabulous!

Dress Code: most likely you can just show up without stinking too much and be alright.

Written Aug 9, 2007

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: A really old style bar
chichecito profile photo

3 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

chichecito 8 reviews
Mc Sorley's waiters
1 more image

I got this spot from a day light tour that I did in the Village. Since then, Mc Sorley's became a unavoidable place to visit every time i'm in New york. It's a very old style irish bar that serves you home made ale, black or light. You can compliment your beers with crackers, cheese and onions, believe me, taste really good.
There are many reasons why this bar is considered a must seen place in New York, probably the most famous one could be that this bar was the last one in New York on let a woman getting in. And that's not a joke.... the newspaper which covered the news is on the wall in front of the bar. The walls are covered with pictures of famous people who shaped the history of the city and the bar is an undeniable character of this history.
The bar is located on 7th street, between the 2nd and Bowery, just one block from St Marks platz, and in front of the Ukrainian church. Take the subway 6 (green) and get off in Astor Place. It's few blocks from there.

Dress Code: Come as you are

Updated Nov 14, 2006

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Related to:
 Beer Tasting
 Study Abroad

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: The Oldest Pub in NY
kucha profile photo

3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

kucha 671 reviews

McSorley's -- a small alehouse with sawdust on the floor to keep it dry (sort of) and relieve the smells (not at all) is one of America's most famous bars, thanks in part to a Life magazine picture essay from 1940 about a day in the life of this alehouse, which was first opened back in 1854 and modeled after an old pub in Ireland the owner (McSorley) remembered from his youth. Prior to that Life expose, artist John Sloan did a series of paintings there -- completed between 1912 and 1930 -- and whenever there was a public exhibition of Sloan paintings, business boomed in the bar. Finally, Joseph Mitchell immortalized the bar in The New Yorker, and his essays were later compiled in the book McSorley's Wonderful Saloon. Woody Guthrie sat at a table with regulars shortly before he headed off to the Merchant Marines. Quite a history, right?

The saloon looks much today as it did 50 years ago in the pages of Life, except the walls are more cluttered with pictures, and those pictures have grown even browner with age. Many politicians were among the regulars, which is one of the reasons that Bill McSorley paid no attention to Prohibition, not even bothering with the customary peephole as he continued to serve beer!

The only reason I was able to visit this bar at all, was thanks to a court case in 1969 which was filed to allow the alehouse to serve women. Prior to that, it was "men-only." Even when I used to go there often (it was right around the corner from my old apartment in the East Village), there was only one unisex bathroom with open-door stalls, a not-so-subtle form of discouraging women according to many. Thus, for women, it was a good idea to go with a friend who could stand guard at the door.

Dress Code: McSorley's ale came from a local brewery, and in 1934 Bill McSorley sold the Fidelio Brewery the right to brew and sell McSorley's Cream Stock Ale. Today, the Stroh Brewing Co. makes the McSorley's Ale sold at the bar and throughout the mid-Atlantic states. The beer is not the real reason to visit the bar, and we wouldn't advocate waiting in the long lines that sometimes appear on weekend nights. Then, it's nearly impossible to get a good look at the place. But on a weekday afternoon, McSorley's remains what we think a saloon is supposed to be.

Written Jul 3, 2006

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: Dark or Lite? Drunk or Sober?
Bela_LUng profile photo

1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Bela_LUng 251 reviews

Holy F. I've been here 3 times - walked in sober, left trashed. I even ate a Liverwurst sammich here! WTF! WHo does that when they are sober?! NO ONE! Beers are sold in either Lite or Dark and in sets of two pints - with a healthy head on them. Go here to get trashed. And punch people.

And yeah, it's the oldest pub in the USA supposedly...looks and smells like it too :)

DRINK BEER!

Dress Code: You must wear only orange pants. This is strictly enforced by killing eels at the door.

Written Dec 10, 2005

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Was this review helpful?

McSorley's Ale House: old pub for NYC
paddymc09 profile photo
paddymc09 92 reviews

not much to eat here, but this place is kinda crazy! always packed when open with a nice mixed croud of people. only two beers on tap lite & dark.
go with the lite, you get like 10 8oz beers for like $1.50 each.

Dress Code: none at all!!

Written Jul 12, 2005

Address: 15 E. 7th St.

Phone: (212) 473-9148

Was this review helpful?

Mc Scoley's Ale House: McScoley's Ale House
Dimi1 profile photo

4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

Dimi1 204 reviews

McSorley's Ale House, 15 E. 7th St. (btw. 2nd Ave. & 3rd Ave.), 473-9148
M-Sa 11am-1am, Su 1pm-1am. Food served.
This is a New York city landmark. They don't serve commercial beer or hard alcohol, only McSorley's own Ale (light or dark).

Written Mar 31, 2005

Was this review helpful?

Top 3 Hotels in New York City

Casablanca Hotel  New York City

 1 Review and 1901 Opinions  This is a Hotel /Bed and Breakfast. It is a oasis in the middle of Times Square. It is quiet inside... 

 Hotels in New York City

Andaz Wall Street  New York City

 1 Review and 595 Opinions  The brand new Andaz by Hyatt is a marvel of modern design done right. The staff and facility are... 

 Hotels in New York City

Library Hotel  New York City

 3 Reviews and 1275 Opinions  The Library is a good little hotel but the frustration is it could be a great hotel. Great concept... 

 Hotels in New York City

The Place

McSorley's Ale House

15 E. 7th St.

McSorley's Ale House tips and photos posted by real travelers and New York City locals.

  Write a Review  
Experience New York City
 

The People

7,506 Members Live Here
 
Our Members Say
 profile photo

 McSorley's Ale House, 15 E. 7th St. (btw. 2nd Ave. & 3rd Ave.), 473-9148 M-Sa 11am-1am, Su 1pm-1am. Food served. This is a New York city landmark. They don't... 

7,506 members live in New York City

 

Questions and Answers

Nifti profile photo

Q:  Hi..soon to be in NYC, there are 3 of us - so 3 suitcases and 3 pieces of hand luggage. Not sure if Cabs are keen on that... 

Agraichen profile photo

A: JFK to Manhattan is regulated for Cabs on price. 3 cases (plus) are about what my wife and daughter carry and they've had no issues. Most NYC cabs can handle a lot more... 

Read 4 Replies

postQuestion_button

Top New York City Writers

1

A NYC GYPSY AT HEART

Gypsystravels profile photo

 I'm a Native New York "Latina". Born and raised in the "City" by Puerto Rican parents. Referred to as a Nuyorican, I'm proud to live in this wonderful, diverse city. It's the largest city in the... 

2

NYC: Everyday, Something new.

cjg1 profile photo

 What do you say about the greatest town in the world? Just like the show business theres no place like it. No place I know. Most of my experiences in this city are an extension of the explorer in...... 

3

I Heart New York.

shutterlust profile photo

 "I LOVE NEW YORK” is the oldest one in the book, conventional wisdom in all caps. And yet, it still somehow retains its potency, and why is that? Because only a fool would think otherwise. Consider...... 

4

"I want to be a part of it ..."

toonsarah profile photo

  Having last visited, and loved, New York City in 1982 (see album below!), we were a little nervous that this repeat visit could prove a disappointment, with the city failing to live up to our... 

5

. : New York City : .

Christophe_Ons profile photo

 New York City has to be the world's greatest, coolest, craziest and certainly most tempting city. On top of that it's the most diverse ethnic/cultural melting pot imaginable. NYC has everything for...... 

View all rated pages

View newest pages

Build your own New York City page

Travel Editors for New York City

vtourist10 profile photo
cjg1 profile photo

New York City Members Meetings

Mar 16, 2012 
St Patrick's Weekend Meet.

see all New York City member meetings