Coney Island, New York City

4 out of 5 stars 20 Reviews

1208 Surf Ave. Brooklyn NY 11224-2816 212-NEW-YORK

Been here? Rate It!

hide
  • Coney Island
    by machomikemd
  • Coney Island
    by machomikemd
  • Coney Island
    by machomikemd
  • JoeM130's Profile Photo

    Safe, Clean, and Very Nostalgic and Fun!

    by JoeM130 Written Aug 27, 2014

    Quick background....I work in law enforcement, I usually am traveling with my family (2 children), and while I do like to explore and I am adventurous, I want to be safe and I don't want to go anywhere that is too trashy. We visit NYC 2 times a year and we have explored most of Manhattan, some of Brooklyn, & Yankee Stadium in the Bronx. I was on the fence on whether to visit Coney Island or not. Was it going to be worth the trip from Manhattan? So I took to Tripadvisor to read the reviews. After reading some of the reviews, I knew that it was going to be nostalgic and fun, but was it clean and safe? The answer is yes. It was clean and safe, and we had lots of fun on a weekend afternoon. We did not do the beach or swim, but here's what we did do. We took the subway there, which drops you off immediately across the street from Nathan's Hot Dogs and the piers. We walked almost the entire boardwalk. We walked out onto the pier which is full of families, fishers, and dog walkers, we ate at Nathan's which was delicious, we rode the Cyclone roller coaster, which is historic by it self, took tons of photos, and then went back to the city. Here's what I experienced. One homeless man asked me for loose change, then politely moved along. Were there some strange, perhaps shady people? Very few! Less than 1%, and none were causing any trouble or concern. There was nothing that you'll experience here that you won't experience in the subway or in any other urban area in the U.S. By the way, uniformed NYPD was present everywhere, even outside of the public bathroom facilities. I did not use the restrooms, but my family did. Apparently they stunk inside and weren't exceptionally clean, but they were safe and usable. As far as cleanliness....It was pretty clean! The boardwalk was in excellent maintained state. The beach and water had no apparent trash. I suspect that when it's really crowded, people do leave bottles, cans, cigarette butts, etc, and while that's a shame, it happens. It was not the Caribbean, and I would not drink the water, but I was not grossed out. I think that if you have visited all of the NYC tourists sites more than once, and you're looking for something nostalgic and different to do, take a few hours on a nice day and venture over to Coney Island. We really enjoyed it and I think that fans of the NYC area should experience it at least once. Enjoy!

    Was this review helpful?

  • machomikemd's Profile Photo

    Coney Island-Famous Amusement Park!

    by machomikemd Updated Jul 14, 2014

    1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    One of America's most celebrated beach resorts during the first half of the 20th Century, Coney Island remains a Mecca for summer fun even today.

    Coney Island is a peninsula, formerly an island, in southernmost Brooklyn, New York City, USA, with a beach lying on the Atlantic Ocean. The eponymous neighborhood is a community of 60,000 people in the western part of the peninsula, with Seagate to its west; Brighton Beach and Manhattan Beach to its east; and Gravesend to the north.

    Coney Island is a seasonal center operating roughly between Easter and Labor Day. Rides and attraction are generally open on weekends from Easter until Memorial Day, all week long from Memorial Day until Labor Day, and then weekends from Labor Day until the end of September. The beach and boardwalk are open all year round (although lifeguards are only on duty from Memorial Day to Labor Day) and Nathan's Hot Dogs and the New York Aquarium are open almost every day of the year. The Coney Island Museum is also open on Saturdays and Sundays, from noon to 5 PM all year round. During the week, rides and attractions may open at noon and run until the late evening. During the weekends, the same rides and attractions open around noon and may run until the early morning.

    Related to:
    • Budget Travel
    • Food and Dining
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

  • CatherineReichardt's Profile Photo

    An old fashioned seaside resort for the masses

    by CatherineReichardt Updated Oct 23, 2012

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    (work in progress)
    It’s difficult to explain why I decided that I needed to visit Coney Island, as it would scarcely feature on the ‘must see’ list for the vast majority of tourists to New York.

    And yet I succumbed to Coney Island’s siren call on a breezy Monday in early October. Maybe it was the nostalgic ‘boardwalk’ factor – a distinctive feature of U.S. beachside culture - and a desire to explore the allure that had inspired musicians artists like Lou Reed, Aerosmith and the Ramones. Or maybe it was the sense of visiting a set from a ‘Scooby Doo’ movie and my morbid fascination for a vintage rickety roller coaster which made such an almighty clatter that every health and safety alarm was registering ‘red alert’.

    In all probability, what tipped the balance was a casual reference in the tour of the superb Tenement Museum to what immigrants did for fun in the little free time that they were afforded. The establishment of the subway system not only facilitated the garment industry’s transition from homebound sweatshops to factories located at some distance from where the workforce lived, but also allowed the workers to travel to Coney Island on the few days off that they were afforded. The image of overworked labourers flocking from overcrowded ghettoes where their working conditions seldom allowed them to venture outside in daylight hours to enjoy a few hours of fresh air and freedom by the seaside was compelling, and I wanted to follow in the footsteps of the immigrant labourers who paid their dues to the U.S. by means of sweat equity and faith in the vision of a better life.

    Was this review helpful?

  • MINOSUKE's Profile Photo

    Going To Coney Island

    by MINOSUKE Updated Aug 30, 2010

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    When I was young, I listened to Lou Reed's 'Coney Island Baby' many times. Since then, I have had a hope to visit there some day. So this time, during my first visit to New York, I took subway, which brought me there in about 1 hour from Central Manhattan.
    When the subway came near Coney Island Station, I could see the Ferris wheel and the jet coaster of an amusement park that had been closed years before.
    I got off at the last stop and walked straight toward the beach.
    The first landmark was the sign of famous hotdog 'Nathan's'. But the first shop I found did not seem to be open. Just in front of the beach there was another Nathan's, where some people were buying coca cola and hotdog.

    Coney Island will be a place for New Yorkers to enjoy swimming and sunbathing in summer. There is a beautiful white beach. Sea gulls. A pier jutting out into the sea to take a walk on.
    An aquarium. I hear the amusement park are being renewed and will be open soon.

    If you are tired from walking too much in the city of NY or from seeing too many great works at Metropolitan Museum, I recommend you to have a visit to Coney Island and rest yourself for a while.

    Coney Island Beach Nathan's Hotdog Pier Sticking out into the Sea Ferris Wheel that is not used
    Related to:
    • Beaches
    • Family Travel
    • Aquarium

    Was this review helpful?

  • apbeaches's Profile Photo

    Coney Island

    by apbeaches Written Jan 16, 2010

    4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    The New York Aquarium first opened on December 10, 1896, making it the oldest continually operating aquarium in the United States. The Aquarium currently occupies 14 acres by the sea in Coney Island, and boasts over 350 species of aquatic wildlife. We enjoy the beluga whales, the shark tanks and the interactive shows with seals and sealions.

    Between about 1880 and World War II, Coney Island was the largest amusement area in the United States, attracting several million visitors per year. At its height it contained three competing major amusement parks, Luna Park, Dreamland, and Steeplechase Park, as well as many independent amusements. Today it looks a bit sad and rundown, but we still had a lot of fun. The Wonder Wheel was built in 1918 and opened in 1920, this steel Ferris wheel has both stationary cars and rocking cars that slide along a track. It holds 144 riders, stands 150 feet tall, and weighs over 2,000 tons. At night the Wonder Wheel's steel frame is outlined and illuminated by neon tubes. The Cyclone roller coaster, built in 1927, is one of the nation's oldest wooden coasters still in operation. The Cyclone includes an 85-foot, 60 degree drop. The Parachute Jump, originally the Life Savers Parachute Jump at the 1939 New York World's Fair still stands.

    Coney Island still maintains a broad sandy beach that is served for its entire length by the broad Riegelmann boardwalk. A number of amusements are directly accessible from the land side of the boardwalk, as is the New York Aquarium and a variety of food shops and arcades. The position of the beach and lack of significant obstructions means virtually the entire beach is in sunlight all day. The beach is open to all without restriction and there is no charge for use. The beach area is divided into "bays", areas of beach delineated by rock jetties, which moderate erosion and the force of ocean waves. The Coney Island Polar Bear Club is a group of people who swim at Coney Island throughout the winter months, most notably on New Year's Day when additional participants join them to swim in the frigid.

    We got a kick out of the Freak Show next to Nathans. We saw men with deformities and "made freaks" that could swallow fire, contort their bodies .. These performers performed magic tricks and daredevil stunts. In addition, the freak show performers might also perform acts or stunts, and would often sell souvenirs like "giant's rings" or "pitch cards" with their photos and life stories. They had a performer who could be viewed for an additional fee.

    The KeySpan Park is home to the Brooklyn Cyclones a minor league baseball team

    Related to:
    • Beaches
    • Family Travel
    • Aquarium

    Was this review helpful?

  • Martinis-At-8's Profile Photo

    Go now while you still can!

    by Martinis-At-8 Written Aug 28, 2007

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    time is running out to visit the world's greatest sideshow. Yes Coney Island is filthy, rundown and has a constant smell of something leaking from the pipes below. But one thing is definite. Whether it is playing Shoot the Freak, eating a Nathan's Famous hotdog, riding the Cyclone or visiting the freakshow, you will find yourself completely entertained by what Coney Island offers... for a limited time only. Next year Astroland is expected to shut down and Coney Island will receive a long overdue deap cleaning. I am not the only one who will miss the grime.

    The legendary Coney Island Nathan's Famous Shoot the Freak - the hottest game in Coney Island

    Was this review helpful?

  • FionaKate's Profile Photo

    Lovely Fairground attractions/Amusment park.

    by FionaKate Written Jan 3, 2007

    When i wentr for a day trip to C island, i had a great time. You can go on one of the old rides or go Go karting. The sea and beach is very beautiful and it is relaxing to get away from thre city for a while.

    Related to:
    • Budget Travel
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

  • moiraistyx's Profile Photo

    CONEY ISLAND HAS SO MUCH TO DO YOUR HEAD WILL SPIN

    by moiraistyx Updated Sep 3, 2006

    3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Anyone who is visiting Brooklyn during the warm months should be obligated to take a stroll through Coney Island. So much of Brooklyn's history, warmth and charm has come from the stories, plays and musicals written about it's neighborhoods. Coney Island is one such neighborhood. It has been featured in numerous movies and TV shows. Coney Island is home to Nathan's Hot Dogs, the best hot dogs in the entire world. It is also home to The Wonder Wheel and the Cyclone. Overall Coney Island has 35 or more rides for visitors to enjoy.

    Coney Island is a seasonal center. Coney Island typically operates from Easter through Labor Day. In general rides and attraction are generally open on weekends between Easter and Memorial Day. One the warm weather hits, they are open all week long until Labor Day, and then weekends from Labor Day until the end of September. The beach and boardwalk are open all year round. Be warey though lifeguards are only on duty from Memorial Day to Labor Day. Nathan's Hot Dogs and the New York Aquarium are open almost every day of the year. The Coney Island Museum is also open on Saturdays and Sundays, from noon to 5 PM all year round.

    Fireworks are sponsored by Astroland and Deno's Wonder Wheel Park every Friday night at 9:30 during the season. As a rule of thumb, fireworks start the last weekend in June and conclude the Friday before Labor Day. Specific questions about the fireworks should be directed to Astroland (718-265-2100) or Deno's (718-449-8836) directly.

    Coney Island also hosts a Saturday Night Film Series sponsored by indiefilmpage.com and Coney Island USA. It. The dates change from year to year, but the location is always the same, The Coney Island Museum at 1208 Sufe Avenue and the time never changes 8:30 PM with doors opening at 8:00 PM. Admission is $5.00 and the popcorn is free.

    THE CYCLONE NATHANS THE WONDER WHEEL
    Related to:
    • Theme Park Trips
    • Family Travel

    Was this review helpful?

  • Fewf's Profile Photo

    Coney Island

    by Fewf Written Aug 3, 2006

    3 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Coney Island was once a huge attraction. It really isn't quite that anymore, but it's still making a big comeback from how it was ten years ago. Since amusement parks are available everywhere now (unlike in the early days of Coney Island), I'd say it's inescapable that it's now more of an attraction for locals than tourists. Tourists want to see something unique.

    Was this review helpful?

  • Upstate1NY's Profile Photo

    Relaxation as a "Business"

    by Upstate1NY Written Apr 28, 2005

    4.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Coney Island the New York City "relaxation center".
    Physically really not that far from the "madding hordes and crowded stores" of Manhatten in space, but a whole "life style" away in "reality". Sand beaches, board walks, amusment rides, sea and waves (no it is not quite "surf"). ENJOY a totally different "side" of NYC AND of all things!! walking the board walk is FREE (of course the subway ride there is not but, still, for a family, (or anyone!) a walk on the shore in NYC is nice

    The Ferris Wheel, Parachute Drop, Steeple Chase
    Related to:
    • Family Travel
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

  • cheryl_the_mermaid's Profile Photo

    Mermaid Parade

    by cheryl_the_mermaid Updated Oct 7, 2004

    3.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    This is the second year in a row that my boyfriend and I have gone to and participated in the mermaid parade! This time it was June, 2004. It's usually in the last week of june, in Coney Island, and basically its a parade full of people dressed up as mermaids, sea creatures, and anything else freaky they can think of like half-fish drag queens and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle mermaids..... for sure the oddest bunch of people I've ever seen in my life, I love it! I myself was a mermaid but my boyfriend was dressed as a 'funky crab'. (I did the costumes by hand, thank you very much!) This year Moby (electronica guy) was King Neptune, leader of the parade. It's right beside Coney Island Beach and you gotta try to Cyclone at Astroland. (rollercoaster) Also the aquarium is cute, better for kids, but I'm a big kid. they got a great walrus there. The freak show was also pretty cool, nothing too insane, but the bug eating was gross. And if they ask you to go to see the speacial feature in the spare room after the show for $2, don't. It's fake.

    John the Funky Crab and Cheryl the Mermaid
    Related to:
    • Gay and Lesbian
    • Festivals
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

  • El_Cookie's Profile Photo

    The Warriors

    by El_Cookie Updated Aug 28, 2004

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    My favorite movie of all time is The Warriors. Its about a gang from Coney Island. I told myself that if I ever went to NYC I would stop by Coney Island. Well I ended up staying there with my friends from Belize.

    Coney Island
    Related to:
    • Singles

    Was this review helpful?

  • JOEYPIN's Profile Photo

    People-Watching

    by JOEYPIN Updated Apr 14, 2004

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    Coney Island.... what an experience!!!
    Just the most tacky, Burlesque place in NY. Loved the themes, rides, people and my particular favourite....Shoot The Freak!!!
    Its a great place to people watch, as it has the widest reaching examples of human life, bar none.
    Also try and ride the 'Cylone' a bit rickerty and old but still great fun!!
    Visit the Coney Island shop selling trinkets and souveneirs. They are tacky but very reminiscent of the 1950's and worth a peek.

    Related to:
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

  • iam1wthee's Profile Photo

    Amusement Park, Beach, and Carnival

    by iam1wthee Updated Feb 18, 2004

    2.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    It mainly appeals to teenagers and under.
    Every year around June there is a mermaid parade and on Independence day there is the famous Nathans Hotdog eating contest that has gotten international fame.

    The train ride from Manhattan is long it is best if you can drive.

    Related to:
    • Theme Park Trips
    • Family Travel

    Was this review helpful?

  • lxine's Profile Photo

    Coney Island

    by lxine Updated Apr 22, 2003

    1.5 out of 5 starsHelpfulness

    This amusement park is so old and nostalgic you can't help but have fun! Be sure to ride The Cyclone, and ancient wooden roller coaster that groans beneath you as you whip around the curves. Take a dip in the ocean and a stroll on the boardwald at the beach there too. It's surprisingly not crowded, huge and pretty clean.

    bathing beauty, teehee!
    Related to:
    • Beaches
    • Theme Park Trips

    Was this review helpful?

Instant Answers: New York City

Get an instant answer from local experts and frequent travelers

39 travelers online now

Comments

Hotels Near Coney Island
3.5 out of 5 stars
2.5 miles away
Show Prices
3.5 out of 5 stars
1 Review
2.8 miles away
Show Prices
3.0 out of 5 stars
1 Review
3.5 miles away
Show Prices

View all New York City hotels